Posts

The Problem Was Never Being Right

The Problem Was Never Being Right

Believing your values are right is not the problem. The problem is when that belief buys you a higher place in the room.

My friend Ajené sent me a research paper last week with four words attached: Just sharing. Saddens me.

I should say plainly that my brain is not wired to absorb this kind of information the way it was intended. I read the methods section twice and understood it the second time about as well as the first. It took me a good while to sift through, and what I came away with is a surface reading at best.

But the surface was enough to stop me.

Five studies. Over a thousand people. The same finding every time.

When a group believes itself morally superior to another group, it begins to perceive the people in that other group as less than fully human. And that perception predicts aggression.

Hmmmmm.

It is not a study about bad actors

Here is what makes it land so hard.

This is not research about extremists, or ideologues, or people with something wrong with them. The researchers ran it on American conservatives and liberals and got the effect on both sides, independent of political orientation. They ran it in China on people who supported and opposed euthanasia. And then — this is the part I keep returning to — they ran it on groups that did not exist.

They gave people a meaningless picture test and told them they had a cognitive style called “Dusek” or “Tausig.” Invented words. Assigned at random, minutes earlier, on the basis of nothing at all. Then they told some of them their invented group was the more virtuous one.

It still happened. People began rating the other invented group as less human. And it predicted aggression toward them.

So this is not about history, or grievance, or the genuine wrongs that real groups have done to one another. Those make it worse, certainly. But the mechanism runs without them. All it needs is a sense that we are the good ones.

It is about ordinary people holding ordinary convictions about what is right.

Where the hope is hiding

I almost stopped reading there. Then I got to the fifth study, and that is where something turned.

The researchers had been tracking two things that usually travel together: the sense that your group is morally superior, and the sense that your group therefore stands higher. In the fifth study they pulled those apart and manipulated them separately.

Neither one alone produced dehumanization.

Not moral superiority on its own. Not a sense of higher standing on its own. Only the two together did it.

Hmmmmm.

Sit with that, because it changes the assignment entirely. Believing your values are right is not the problem. You are allowed to think some things are better than other things. You are allowed to have convictions, and the contemplative traditions have never asked anyone to give them up.

The problem comes when that belief converts into a sense of standing above. About being better than.

That middle step is where the damage enters. It is also the step nobody notices themselves taking.

And the researchers found something practical: when they emphasized equal standing between the groups, the whole effect weakened — even among people whose sense of moral superiority was running high. The work is not to hold our convictions more loosely. It is to stop letting them purchase us a higher place in the room.

Now the uncomfortable part

I have been sitting with this for several days, and here is where it finally caught me.

I have a wall of certificates that say I am self-aware. Master Certified Coach. Certified spiritual director. Narrative Enneagram teacher. I had never once thought to put that wall next to a study about moral superiority, and I am not enjoying the view now that I have.

Because inner work is a credential. And a credential confers standing.

Early in my coaching, before I understood the depth of what it actually means to be a coach, I watched someone else trying to do it. And I thought: that person should not be a coach.

I was looking at the outside of them from the outside of me. I had no idea what was happening in that room, or in them, or what they were carrying into it.

I see it differently now. Though I want to be honest about why. What changed me was going further into the ICF mentor coach work — more training, more assessment, another credential. So the thing that corrected my judgment was the same kind of thing that produced it in the first place. I am not sure what to do with that. I am suspicious of any version of this story where I come out clean.

There is a sentence I have heard in good rooms full of serious people, and I have said it myself more than once. They’re just not very self-aware.

Look at what that sentence does. It is a moral claim — awareness is a virtue in our world, maybe the central one. And it is a status claim in the same breath: I have the thing, they lack it, and that places us. Moral superiority plus perceived standing. Exactly the combination the fifth study isolated, delivered in a warm tone of voice.

We have a particularly refined version, too, because ours comes with humility built into the vocabulary. We can say bless them, they’re doing their best with the awareness they have and mean something quite unkind by it. The language of formation is unusually good at carrying contempt without leaving fingerprints.

I teach the Enneagram, which means I help people discover that there are nine distinct ways of being better than everyone else, and that theirs has a number. I say that as a joke. I am about forty percent sure it is one.

Why the tradition built the fences it did

This is where the old practices stop looking quaint to me.

The desert fathers and mothers had an almost absolute prohibition on judging another monk — not as etiquette, but as something closer to a safety rule. There are stories about a brother caught in open sin and the elders refusing to say a word against him. That always struck me as excessive. I am less sure now.

Consider the examen. It is turned inward, always, on yourself. There is no version of the practice where you examine the day’s conduct of other people. That is not an accident of design. It is a discipline built by people who had watched what happens when a sincere person starts keeping accounts on somebody else’s behavior, and who built the instrument so it could only point one direction.

The traditions were not naïve about human goodness. They were worried about exactly this — and worried enough to build fences that look, from the outside, like they go much too far.

Catching The Conversation Workbook

What I think we actually do

I do not think the answer is to stop having convictions. I hold mine. Some things are better than other things and I am not going to pretend otherwise at seventy-four.

What I think we do is watch for the conversion.

Notice the moment a conviction turns into a position. There is a specific feeling to it, and once you know the feeling you can catch it: a small lift, a settling, a sense of having been placed correctly in relation to someone. It is pleasant. That is what makes it so hard to see. It arrives disguised as clarity.

And then do the thing the fifth study says actually works, which is harder than it sounds. Put yourself back on level ground with the person you have just placed below you. Not by pretending you agree with them. By remembering that being right about a thing does not raise you one inch above anybody.

Ajené wrote that this saddens him, and it does. But I came away with something else as well, which I did not expect from a psychology paper.

The invitation is not to be less certain.

It is to stop standing on it.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Source

Zhang et al. (2026). When virtues are weaponized: Moral superiority aggravates outgroup dehumanization. Political Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1111/pops.70140

The Desert and What Holds Weight

The Desert and What Holds Weight

Part Three of a Three-Part Conversation with Eric Pennington

There is a particular kind of man who can tell you, without flinching, exactly what a decade cost him — and then tell you, in the same breath, that he wouldn’t trade it. Eric Pennington is that man. I have known him for years now. I have watched him work rooms full of skeptical engineers and rooms full of grieving people and rooms full of executives who didn’t yet know they needed what he was offering. And nothing I have watched him do has prepared me for what it was like to sit across from him and ask him to open the desert back up, on camera, on purpose.

He calls it the desert. Sometimes the crucible — the older, harder word, the one that means the fire applied to ore until everything that isn’t the metal itself burns away. He doesn’t reach for that word for effect. He reaches for it because it’s accurate. The crucible doesn’t ask your permission. It doesn’t negotiate a timeline. It simply burns, for as long as burning is required, and you find out what you’re actually made of only after there’s nothing left to hide behind.

His began in 2006. It didn’t end, by his own accounting, until somewhere around 2017. Eleven years, give or take. I want you to sit with that number for a moment before we go further, because it would be easy to read past it. Eleven years is not a bad quarter. It is not a rough season. It is the better part of a man’s working life, spent not knowing, year after year, whether the ground would ever hold again.

“You can confidently say — yeah, I know I’m in the desert, but I’m sure probably next month we’ll be out of here,” he told me. “And then it’s not. And then you realize after a couple of years: yeah. You are in the desert.” He said it almost gently, the way people describe a wound long enough healed that they can finally hold it up to the light without flinching. But I watched his face while he said it, and I want to be honest with you: there was nothing easy underneath that gentleness. Eleven years of believing the end was near and being wrong, over and over, is not a small thing to survive with your faith intact. Most people don’t. Eric did.

I asked him what the desert took from him that he hadn’t expected to lose.

“A lot of that pride,” he said immediately. No hedging. No softening it into something more palatable. He traced it back through everything we’d uncovered in the two conversations before this one — a childhood where being right felt like the only available form of safety, a corporate career that rewarded the same instinct with money and promotions and the particular drug of applause, a company called Epic Living that he launched half out of genuine vision and half out of an old hunger still looking for its next hit. The desert went after all of it. “It birthed in me what I would say is authentic humility,” he said — and he meant the word authentic as a precise distinction, not a flourish. He has seen the performed version of humility up close. He knows it when he sees it, because he used to wear it himself. What the desert gave him instead was the kind you don’t get to choose. The kind that’s simply what’s left.

And then there were the mirages. I want to dwell on this, because I think it is one of the most honest things a person has ever said to me about suffering. A mirage in the desert isn’t an absence of hope — it’s hope, fully formed, arriving exactly when you need it, and then revealing itself as nothing. “You thought: I’m this close. There it is,” Eric said. “And then — gone. And another lesson to learn.” He didn’t say this with bitterness. He said it the way a man says something he has made an uneasy peace with, after enough years of practice, while still being honest that the peace was hard-won and is not the same thing as the pain having been small.

What grew in that soil, against every reasonable expectation, was something he attributes — without irony, in the middle of an interview about emotional intelligence — to Søren Kierkegaard. The idea of playing for an audience of one. Not performing for the room. Not measuring the work by who noticed it. Doing the work because the one true audience already knows the whole of your story, has already seen you at your most desperate and your most petty, and remains, somehow, still interested. I watched something settle in him when he said it. Like a man finally putting down something heavy he’d been carrying with both arms for over a decade.

This is the thing I most want you to understand about Eric Pennington: he refuses to simplify himself for your comfort or mine. In the span of a single answer he will move from Kierkegaard to the Enneagram to Miles Davis to a streaming television show, and somehow none of it is scattered. All of it is the same man, looking at the same wound from different angles, refusing to let any single lens claim the whole truth.

I asked him directly about the cost of being who he is — an empath, by his own naming, a self-preservation Four on the Enneagram, a man built to feel things at a depth this culture rarely makes room for, especially in men. His answer stopped me. “I’m an alien,” he said. “It feels like an alien.” Not with grief, though grief lives somewhere underneath it. With something closer to ownership. “I say that in recognition that I am here, and I’m here for a purpose.” He told me about a character on a television show he’d recently found himself drawn to — a figure who moves through the world differently than everyone around him, sees what others miss, is somehow both fully present and permanently a step outside. He used the word archetype without my prompting him toward it. He told me that the word “weird” used to land on him as wound, the way it landed on a boy who’d already survived more before age fourteen than most people survive in a lifetime. Now it lands as confirmation. “It added to my confidence and courage,” he said, “to continue to be who I know myself to be.”

I do not think most people get to that sentence. I think most people spend their whole lives running from the very thing Eric has learned to stand inside.

Then I asked him the question I had been most afraid to ask, because I suspected the answer would require more of him than any other question in three conversations: what is actually happening inside you, underneath, in the moment before you’ve found the words for something heavy?

He went quiet. Not an uncomfortable quiet — a deliberate one, the kind a musician takes before the next phrase. And then he gave me an answer I will be thinking about for a long time.

“It’s these notes,” he said. “If you’re familiar with music from a theory standpoint — you have quarter notes, you have half notes, you have whole notes, and then you have pauses that can be in between. That’s probably one of the gifts of music for me. It allowed me to process what’s happening underneath — that depth — and to be present with it. Because I can hold that note, and allow that liminal space to do what it does. And then play another note.” He brought Miles Davis back into it, the way he always eventually does — not the man’s sound, but his restraint. “It’s not how many notes. It’s what notes you choose. And the timing of them.” That, he told me, is the medicine. Not rushing toward resolution. Not explaining the ache before it’s finished teaching him something. Holding the note as long as the note needs to be held.

I have interviewed a great many people in my work. I have rarely heard anyone describe their own interior life with that much precision, or that much tenderness toward themselves.

We arrived, finally, at the question I had been saving across all three conversations — the one I think every other question had been quietly building toward. I reminded him of something he had told me himself: that his desire, underneath everything else, is to create things that will hold weight in eternity. And I asked him plainly: when you look back on this season of your life, what do you hope will have held that weight?

He answered slowly, on three levels, and I want to give you his words as close to whole as I can.

First — that he had been growing, across the whole of his life, into the person God intended him to be before he was ever formed in his mother’s womb.

Second — that his relationships would carry something real. That Jim, and Lynette, his wife, his children, the people he has walked closest to, would be able to say, without exaggeration: you did well there. We were helped. We were enriched by being near you.

Third — that the work itself, the podcasts and the articles and the coaching conversations no one ever sees the other side of, would have made a genuine difference in lives he will never personally know about. People who will never write him a message saying it mattered. He is not asking for the credit. He is asking that the giving was real, regardless of whether anyone ever tells him so.

The Desert And What Holds Weight Reflection Sheet

I have sat across from Eric Pennington enough times now to say this without exaggeration: I believe all three of those things will have been true. Not because he has learned to say the right words in the right order — he is far too honest a man for that kind of performance — but because eleven years in a desert burned away everything in him that wasn’t load-bearing, and what is left underneath is, simply, real. The boy who once watched his own life happen to him from a small distance, who found a lifeline in a hymn and a jazz record at thirteen, who carried a brother’s worst day into a school hallway where everyone already had a story about him, who chased the applause until it stopped feeding him, who walked eleven years of mirages and came out still able to play for an audience of one — that boy became, against very long odds, an extraordinary man. I am grateful to call him my friend. I think, by the time you finish reading this, you may understand why.

Where this meets you: what are you building right now that you hope will still mean something in a room you will never enter?

Peace and every good.

About the Author

Jim Vaive is co-founder of spirit of EQ, where he and his wife Lynette help individuals, leaders, and teams grow through emotional intelligence, the Enneagram, and contemplative spiritual formation. He writes at The Mystical Seeker on the inward life that makes the outward work possible.