Posts

Beholding: Learning to See What’s Always There

/0 Comments/in /by

The Art of Beholding: Learning to See What Has Always Been There

There is a particular quality of light that appears in the late afternoon of an Ohio April. It arrives low and amber, slanting through leaves that have already begun their eager growth to bright greens. If you are moving fast enough — hurrying to a car, glancing at a phone, managing the thousand small demands of a day — you will miss it entirely. Not because it isn’t there. Because you haven’t learned to behold it.

Beholding is an old word. It carries weight in it, a kind of gravity. We use “seeing” now, or “looking,” but beholding suggests something more — a sustained, willing act of attention that changes both the one who gazes and the thing being gazed upon. It is, in its truest form, a practice. And like all practices, it has a history.

An Ancient Hunger

Long before cell phones, before television, before the printing press turned information into a torrent, human beings struggled to pay attention. The desert fathers and mothers of fourth-century Egypt walked out into the Saharan silence precisely because the noise of Alexandria made attention impossible. They were not fleeing the world so much as trying to see it. To behold it, without the distortion of constant stimulation.

The medieval contemplatives — Hildegard of Bingen, Meister Eckhart, Julian of Norwich — built entire theologies around the act of sustained looking. Julian, sealed in a small room attached to a church in Norwich, spent decades beholding a series of visions she called her “showings.” She looked at them not once but repeatedly across a lifetime, returning, noticing new things, going deeper. Her great work, Revelations of Divine Love, is less a transcript of mystical experience than a record of what happens when someone refuses to look away.

What they all understood — and what we are slowly, painfully rediscovering — is that attention is not passive. It is not what happens when you have nothing else to do. It is, as spiritual writer Amy Frykholm describes it, a form of discipline every bit as demanding as any physical practice. “The practice of beholding,” she writes, “takes desire and discipline.” The desire is the easier part. We often want to see more deeply, feel more fully, live with more presence. The discipline is where most of us quietly give up.

A Story About a Garden

I remember when my grandmother kept a garden in the backyard of a house in a small Michigan town up in the thumb area. It was not a grand garden — a few beds, a few tomato stakes listing to one side, herbs growing in a few terra cotta pots along the fence. But she tended it with a quality of attention I didn’t understand as a child and have spent most of my adult life trying to remember these times of quiet and what they meant.

She would go out in the mornings, before it was fully light, and simply stand in it. Not weeding, not harvesting, not doing anything that could be explained by utility. Just standing. Sometimes she held a cup of coffee. Sometimes she didn’t. I asked her once what she was doing. She thought about it for a moment and said: I’m watching it wake up. WOW!

I thought she was being poetic. Now I think she was being precise.

She had learned, through years of practice, to behold. To give her full attention to something outside herself without immediately needing to act on it, explain it, or use it for something else. She was, in the language of the contemplatives, practicing presence. And the garden — the wet soil smell, the hum of early insects, the way light moved through bean leaves like green stained glass — the garden held her in return.

The Difficulty Is the Point

Frykholm names the struggle honestly: “Don’t underestimate the paradigm shift required for the act of beholding, just how different it is from our everyday lives and just how shiny and compelling our everyday life will seem when we propose pausing.”

This is not a problem technology created. Technology has sharpened it, given it new urgency, made distraction faster and more elegant. But the problem itself is ancient. The mind that wanders from prayer in a stone monastery cell and the mind that reaches for its phone in the middle of a sunset are doing the same thing: fleeing the discomfort of full presence.

Because presence is uncomfortable. To truly behold something — a person, a landscape, an idea, a grief — is to become vulnerable to it. You cannot behold something and remain entirely in control of what it means to you or what it does to you. This is why beholding is an act of courage as much as attention.

And then there is the second difficulty Frykholm names, the one that arrives even after we’ve managed to sit still. Our own thoughts. The internal narrator who cannot stop generating commentary, to-do lists, memories, anxieties. “Any act of attention is not a sustained experiencing,” she writes. “It’s a series of successive efforts to bring attention back to the same thing, considering it again and again.”

This reframe is quietly revolutionary for us. We tend to judge ourselves harshly for the mind that wanders — as though a wandering mind is evidence of failure. But Frykholm describes the return itself as the practice. Every time you bring your attention back, you are training something. You are doing the work. The wandering is not the obstacle. The returning is the path.

What Beholding Makes of Us

My grandmother died on a cold day in November. The garden had long gone to frost by then. But on the morning of her funeral, I went outside and stood in my own backyard — not her backyard, mine, a inner city lot quite different then hers — and tried to do what I had watched her do. I tried to behold. Her passing touched a part of me that needed to wake up.

The sky was the gray of Midwestern November, cold, stark, the kind that seems to press down gently on everything beneath it. A cardinal landed on the fence, bright as a wound, and regarded me with one black eye. I noticed my thoughts moving immediately toward meaning — a sign, she’s here, she’s saying goodbye — and I watched myself doing it, watched the mind rushing to make the moment useful, to metabolize it into narrative.

So, I came back. To the cardinal. To the gray sky. To the cold that was starting to find the gaps in my coat.

And for a few seconds — Frykholm says sometimes it is only a few seconds — something opened. The fence and the bird and the sky and my grief and the cold and the smell of dead leaves all existed together without needing to be explained or arranged. I was held by it.

“Whatever you behold,” Frykholm writes, “you eventually become beholden to. You enter into a love relation.”

This is the fruit of the practice: not escape from the world, not transcendence of the ordinary, but a deepening into it. A recognition of what has always been present, waiting for us to slow down long enough to receive it. The interconnected, openhearted world, as she puts it, welcomes us — not as strangers who finally arrived, but as the ones it has been waiting for all along.

My grandmother knew this. The desert fathers knew it. Julian knew it, sealed in her small stone room, looking and looking and looking.

The light is still there, amber and low, arriving every October afternoon.

We are still learning to see it.

Peace and every good

 

As cited by the Center for Action and Contemplation.

Chicago/Turabian: Frykholm, Amy. Journey to the Wild Heart. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 2025, pages 28–30.

Walking Together: Quiet Practices of Contemplation

/0 Comments/in , /by

Some of you may have of heard about contemplation and written it off as a bunch of woo woo. But contemplation is less a set of techniques and more a shared journey inward—one we take together, step by quiet step. It slowly rewires our brains so we can meet reality as it is: without judgment, without comparison. That transformation doesn’t happen overnight. It is gentle and cumulative, like water shaping stone. Along the way we can find many paths—chanting, breath work, sitting in silence, moving with intention—and each one invites us to hold everything that arises, both joy and sorrow, in a single, loving presence.

How does that sound so far?

Imagine us walking a path that begins in ordinary life. The day presses in deadlines, relationships, the small urgencies that crowd our attention. Most of us learn to react quickly—assess, compare, jump to solution. These habits serve immediate needs but harden into patterns that narrow perception. Contemplation invites us to widen our view. It asks us to notice how we notice, to befriend the raw material of experience rather than pushing it away or pinning it to a story.

I want to tell you about two people I’ve walked with (both with permission)—Susan and Robert—because their stories are not lessons to perfect, but companions along the trail.

Susan’s life felt noisy. Her father’s illness filled the house with schedules, calls, and the relentless inner commentary that turned every decision into a moral exam. She began waking at night with her chest tight, images and judgments replaying like an old film. A counselor suggested she try five minutes before dawn: sit, breathe, and simply be.

The first mornings felt absurdly small. The mind leapt from one worry to another, and Susan wanted/needed to “do” something—fix, plan, save, prevent. Instead, she learned an art of returning: (more on this subject later) notice the thought, name it (“worry,” “planning”), soften back to the breath. This part is important, because those five minutes did not erase her responsibilities; they made her able to carry them differently. The racing that used to stay with her all morning lifted. In conversations with her father, she discovered a steadier presence—less urgency, more listening. The practice didn’t change the facts of his illness, but it changed how she lived inside those facts. Contemplation became the quiet harbor she returned to when the sea of life grew rough.

 

Robert’s day held a strange juxtaposition: a long-awaited promotion and the sudden loss of a friend. He thought the right move was to split the feelings—celebrate at work, grieve in private. But the separation felt precarious, as if one life could not sustain both truth and grief. A friend invited him to sit in silence each evening and simply allow whatever was present. At first Robert bristled; there is something unnerving about giving grief permission to sit beside joy. Yet, as nights passed, unexpected things happened: laughter would arise in the middle of tears; a memory brightened the next day’s work; the two truths began to coexist with fewer ruptures.

These stories are not heroic. They’re ordinary evidence that when we practice together—when we commit to small, shared acts of attention—our interior landscape changes. Contemplation does not aim to make us perfect. It offers a steadying alchemy: and this is key, the ability to notice what’s happening without immediately becoming it. A breath becomes an anchor. A chant becomes a shared pulse. A silent sitting becomes a room where the mind can lay down the heavy burdens of judgment and comparison.

There are different ways to travel this inner landscape. Sometimes we sit and listen, letting the silence teach us how loud our lives have been. Sometimes we use sound—repeating a phrase, a mantra, a chant—so the mind has a steady thread to follow back when it wanders. Sometimes we move with attention, walking slowly until each footfall becomes a meditation. None of these is a destination; each is a doorway. Together, they form the landscape of a contemplative life: varied, alive, and practical.

I invite you now to picture a day of shared, small practices—please, not as a checklist but as moments where we meet ourselves. Morning might begin with a few breaths, a communal inhale that reminds us we are alive and present. Later, when midday fatigue sets in, a short whisper of a mantra can be a thread that pulls us home. In the afternoon, a slow walk with a friend—no agendas, just steps—becomes a moving conversation between body and world. Evening can be the time we sit in silence and allow the day’s textures—joys, sorrows, confusions—to rest together in one field of attention.

Rumi’s poem here says it all.

Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and right doing,
There is a field. I’ll meet you there.
When the soul lies down in that grass,
The world is too full to talk about.
Ideas, language, even the phrase each other
Doesn’t make any sense.

On this path, what changes is not our need for love, success, safety, or meaning. Those needs persist. What changes is our relationship to them. Contemplation teaches us to notice the story-making mind—the one that compares, judges, and colors experience with old fears. Instead of neutralizing feelings, we learn to enlarge the capacity that holds them. We become more capable of carrying paradox: grief and gratitude, loss and possibility, fatigue and wonder. The result is not stoic suppression but a kind of spacious intimacy with life.

There is a tenderness in learning alongside others. Practicing with a friend, a small group, or even in a city park where strangers sit in the same silence creates a subtle reciprocity. Each person’s steadiness supports the others. We become witnesses to one another’s interior worlds, without the demands of fixing or advising. In that shared attention, something else is cultivated: humility. We remember that everyone carries hidden weight. We learn to offer simple acknowledgments— “I see you,” “I’m here”—that, in their quietness, are often enough.

This is not a prescription for ignoring injustice or avoiding action. Contemplation can deepen our capacity for compassionate action. When we don’t rush to judgment, we’re better able to discern the right next step. We act from clarity rather than from the quick comfort of being right. In this way, contemplative practice becomes a form of social courage, because it helps us face hard truths without closing.

The journey is patient. It does not demand dramatic change. It starts with small, shared choices—breathing before reaching for the phone, exchanging a few minutes of silence with another, walking slowly with attention. Over time, those choices rewire us. The brain’s old grooves remain, but new pathways form that allow for a kinder, steadier response to life’s surprises.

So let us travel together. Let us try a breath, a chant, a silent sitting, a mindful step. Let us notice when comparison or judgment arises and gently bring ourselves back to what’s here. When sorrow visits, we will not exile joy. When joy arrives, we will not pretend sorrow is absent. We will learn to hold both with a broad, loving hand.

Contemplation asks only for presence. It asks us to be there for the small moments because they are the scaffolding of the large ones. In the ordinary repetitions of daily life—cups of tea, brief phone calls, evening walks—there is an invitation: to slow, to notice, to hold. In accepting that invitation together, we find that our lives are not fractured into neat compartments but held in a single, warming field of attention. Joy and sorrow sit beside one another, seen and loved. And gradually, without fanfare, our minds and hearts rearrange to meet the world as it is—open, compassionate, and awake.