Reflections on mindfulness as contemplative attention — the presence and patience it takes to actually be where you are. These posts explore where mindfulness and the contemplative life meet.

The Elder Is the One Who Can Be Asked

For thirteen years Lynette and I have been going to the same spiritual director.

Two chairs. A drink set down beside each of us. That particular few seconds before anyone speaks, when you both know what you came to say and neither of you has started. We go there to say out loud the things that do not get said anywhere else — and I have noticed that nothing gets said out loud in that room until somebody asks.

It happened in that room. I could not tell you now what had just been said — only that somebody had said something true, and in the quiet afterwards the holy crap light came on.

Not a thought. A piece of information arriving from lower down than thinking: this has changed. You are not the one carrying it any more. You are the one it gets brought to.

And the part I did not expect, and still cannot entirely explain, is that it was all right.

Hero to Elder

Connie Zweig, a psychotherapist who spent a career in the work before writing The Inner Work of Age, has a name for this passage. She calls it the shift from role to soul, and underneath it the move from Hero to Elder. I reached for the words doing to being before I ever read her, which I take as evidence that the thing is real and she simply got there first with language.

The Hero’s unit of value is capacity — what he can carry, fix, build, protect. I ran on that for forty years, and I have written elsewhere about the bill. The drive was not fair to the people around me, and some are still paying for it. That is the Hero’s characteristic damage. Not malice. Force, applied to people who had not asked for it.

The Elder’s unit of value is availability. Not what he can carry. What he can be asked.

Why the Hero cannot answer the only question that matters

I have been circling one question: what is mine to do?

It took me an embarrassing while to see why it would not resolve. The question is unanswerable to a Hero, because the Hero’s answer is always all of it. I am an Eight on the Enneagram, and here is what an Eight does — sees something shiny in the sand, rushes over, picks it up, turns it into something. Each time the thing was real and worth doing. Each time the picking-up was automatic.

Discernment requires something to decline with. You cannot sort what is yours from what is merely available while your sense of yourself depends on being able to take all of it. The move from hero to elder is not a pleasant development in late life. It is the thing that makes the question answerable at all.

What stands in the way is not time

Zweig came to this from shadow work — she co-wrote Meeting the Shadow long before she wrote about age. What blocks the passage is not the calendar. It is unconscious material: the denial and resistance that erupt at the thresholds of later life, mostly out of sight of the person they are happening to.

Every type has a version. For an Eight the disowned thing is need — not weakness in general, but the state of requiring something from someone who might not give it. I spent decades building a life in which that state was impossible, and I called the result strength.

Which is why the afternoon in that car park outside Florence went the way it did. Our car had been emptied, my passport with it, and I had been competent at a robbery all day. Then two colleagues arrived and asked what I needed first, and the thing I had spent forty years keeping out of the room walked in, and I could not hold it.

That is shadow doing what shadow does, and it is why a Hero cannot decide to become an Elder on a Tuesday. The material has to be met, and it does not surface on request. It surfaces when something takes your passport.

Where I already made the move, and where I have not

Here is the part I did not expect to find when I started writing this.

I have been doing elderhood for twenty years, professionally, without noticing. In the chair with a client or a directee, the one thing I will not do is tell them what to do. The choice is theirs, the consequences are theirs, and the only thing I have worth anything is a question they had not thought to ask themselves. People tell me, in almost the same phrase, that I never tell them what to do. I used to hear that as a compliment about technique. I think now it is a description of the office.

So the transition is not ahead of me at work. It is unfinished everywhere else.

An Eight fights for the people he cares about. That is my line and I have said it proudly. But I can let a client have their own consequences all day long, and whether I can let the people I love have theirs is a different question. I do not like my answer. The Hero is still fully operational in exactly the places where I care most.

A word, not a plan

An older man in the foreground watches a group of people seated around a table in conversation outdoors in warm afternoon light.

The monastics who went out into the Egyptian desert in the fourth century had no credentialing body — no application, no committee, no letters after anyone’s name. People walked out to where somebody was living, sat down, and said: abba, give me a word. Amma, if it was a woman. That was the whole transaction. Not a program, not a strategy — a word, something short and often strange, which the asker carried around for a year.

Notice who made the elder. The askers did. The office existed because people kept coming, and it would have ended the day they stopped. Which is the same shape as the thing I learned in Italy: an identity handed to you by other people, with no document in the transaction.

It also explains why advice is the Hero’s instrument and a word is the Elder’s. The Hero knows, and the knowing is proof of capacity. A word is offered and let go of, and whether anything comes of it is none of the giver’s business. You cannot give a word while you are still using your answers to prove something.

You cannot claim it. You can only become askable.

So what do you do, if you want the office and nobody is handing it out? Nothing that looks like applying. An elder who announces himself is seniority with a grievance. The only move available is to become the kind of person it makes sense to ask — reachable, honest about what you got wrong, done performing wisdom, and willing to be asked at an inconvenient hour by someone whose problem is not interesting.

Then the other half. The elder is not only the one who can be asked. The elder is the one who asks. Not let me know if you need anything, which hands the work back to the person already underwater. The four words two Italians used on me in a car park: what do you need first?

Anyone who asks that is doing the office, whatever their age.

What it costs, and the word I used

I will not pretend this is painless. It means being consulted less than you are capable of advising, with your influence running entirely on other people choosing to ask. After forty years of needing nobody’s permission to act, that is a real loss and I feel it.

What you get is larger and harder to name. The Hero is exhausting to be and exhausting to be near. People brace around a Hero. Nobody braces around an elder, which is exactly why they come.

Zweig was initiated as an Elder in a formal ceremony by a community that still performs them, and I am glad such things exist. But the ceremony did not make her one — it recognised something already underway. The rite ratifies; it cannot manufacture.

Which settles the question I have been circling since the passport. Everything else that proves me was issued by somebody and can be taken back in an afternoon — the title, the credentials, the body, the document in the drawer. This one is different, and not because it is more secure. It is different because it was never issued at all.

It is not a rank. It is a practice. And when I understood that, the word that came was not finally, and it was not at last. It was all right — the weight off the back arriving not as triumph but as permission.

Two chairs. A drink beside each of us. Somebody older than me has been doing this so quietly, for thirteen years, that it took me most of that time to notice it was a job.

A companion reflection sheet for this post: Who Comes to You (PDF).

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim Vaive and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ, where they work with leaders and seekers worldwide in coaching, training, and spiritual direction. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Dr. Lynette Vaive’s doctoral research is the scholarly foundation of the Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) framework. Together they write The Mystical Seeker on Substack and are co-authoring a book on SEQ. Reach them at jim@spiritofeq.com and lynette@spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Connie Zweig, The Inner Work of Age: Shifting from Role to Soul (Park Street Press, 2021), foreword by Harry R. Moody. Zweig is also co-author of Meeting the Shadow.

The form “give me a word” is from the sayings of the Desert Fathers and Mothers (the Apophthegmata Patrum), fourth-century Egypt.

Richard Rohr, “Our Life’s Call,” Daily Meditations, Center for Action and Contemplation, 13 November 2026.

© 2026 Spirit of EQ

What the Passport Couldn’t Prove

The car was empty when we came back to it. A village square an hour outside Florence, September light coming sideways across the stones, and the rental car standing open like something that had been hollowed out. Luggage gone. Backpacks gone. Computers, iPads, the chargers, the notes I had made on the plane. We were on our way from the airport to a castle in Tuscany, for a week of learning and facilitating. Lynette and I looked at each other over the roof of the car and laughed.

I have thought about that laugh for ten years. It arrived before anything else did — before the inventory, before the police report, before the slow understanding of what had left with the bags. Whatever I am, it laughed first.

What left with the bags was my passport.

What a Passport Is

It is worth looking at what a passport is, because it is a strange object to grieve. It is issued. Someone else certifies that you are who you say you are, and strangers accept the certification on that authority rather than yours. It only matters at borders; at home it lies in a drawer for years. And it says almost nothing true about you — a name, a date, a place of birth, a photograph taken under fluorescent light on a bad morning. It attests that you exist and where you are from. Nothing about what you love, what you have repented of, what you would weep over. The thinnest possible description of a person. And standing in that square, I understood that I had no way to prove who I was.

What Do You Need First?

Two Italian colleagues drove out to help us. I remember very little about the logistics and everything about one sentence. They asked, “What do you need first?”

And I cried.

Not when the car was emptied. Not when I understood the passport was gone. When two people who did not require any documentation asked me what I needed.

That question is addressed to a someone. It assumes there is a person standing there with needs, prior to any paperwork, and it was the first question in days I could not answer by producing something. I had nothing to hand anyone. And the strange grace of that week was that nothing was required. We spent days getting the language wrong and the customs wrong, and the Italians were gentle with us anyway — patient with our fumbling, warm without cause, entirely uninterested in whether we could establish our standing.

My identity that week was not recovered by looking inward. It was handed to me by other people, freely, with no document in the transaction.

A Stack of Passports

A man with a leather backpack seen from behind, standing before the arched entrance of the United States Embassy beneath an American flag.

I have been turning this over again lately because of a question I cannot put down: what is mine to do? Richard Rohr writes that “your life is not about you” — that we are an instance of something larger living itself through us (Center for Action and Contemplation). Parker Palmer, in Let Your Life Speak, says that before we tell our lives what we intend to do with them, we should “listen for what it intends to do with you.” Palmer was in his early thirties when that question woke him. I am seventy-four.

Which makes it a different question. Palmer’s version is a correction for willfulness — I have been chasing borrowed ideals, let me listen for the life that is already mine. Mine is narrower and more exacting: of the things that are genuinely mine, which ones do I still have the time and the strength for?

And underneath that one, a harder one. Who is the person who would do them?

I have no academic degrees. My whole public self is a stack of conferred identities — master certified coach, certified spiritual director, certified teacher of this, certified practitioner of that. Decades of accumulating documents that attest to who I am, each one real, each one earned in hours nobody saw. A stack of passports. And in a square outside Florence I learned how much of that I could carry across a border where none of it was recognized.

I do not think the credentials are false. That is the easy move and it is not honest. The letters describe what I have done, and the hours behind them are real. The passport was true. It just was not me.

Who Are We Without the Thing That Proves Us?

The question does not require a theft. It arrives on its own schedule, and it comes for everyone. Who are you when the title goes — when the business card no longer explains you at a party, when the organization you ran runs fine without you, when the role you filled for twenty years is filled by someone else and filled well? Who are you when the marriage ends, or when the person who knew you longest dies and takes with them the only remaining witness to your younger self? Who are you when the body stops cooperating — when the knee that carried you up mountains will not take the stairs, when the mind that held nine things at once holds four? Each of these is a passport. Each of them is issued by something outside you. Each of them can be taken in an afternoon.

There May Be No Then

Here I want to say something about the version of this question I am living with now, and you can skip the paragraph if you would rather.

I have an aorta that is enlarged. It could give way without warning. There is also a cyst on my pancreas that gets watched. This is not terminal illness, which hands you a prognosis and lets you plan a final act. It is not ordinary mortality either, the statistical fog the rest of us ignore successfully. It is mortality with a vivid mechanism and no timeline. I can neither plan around it nor forget it.

What that destroys is the sequenced life. The ordinary way we answer “what is mine to do” is in an order of operations — finish the book, then build the thing, then rest. An aorta like mine invalidates sequencing, because there may be no then. So the question changes shape in my hands. It stops being in what order? and becomes: what would I want to be in the middle of?

I would offer that one to you whether or not anything in your chest is enlarged. Sequencing is a fiction for all of us. Some of us have just been informed.

Smaller Than Anyone Promises

I would offer one correction to the thing we usually say about the end of a life — that the small things fall away and only the big ones remain, love and God and the people. It sounds right and I do not think it is true. What survived that week in Italy was not a revelation. It was Lynette’s face over the roof of a car. It was two people asking a practical question. It was a village being kind while we got everything wrong. What is left when you are stripped turns out to be smaller and more particular than anyone promises — not love but a specific face, not service but the one person you would still sit with on a Tuesday.

Taken In Without Papers

There is one more piece, and it is the one I would least like to say out loud. I am an Eight on the Enneagram. My whole life is organized around capacity — I can handle this, I can carry it, I will be the one who does not need help. An enlarged aorta is the one thing that cannot be handled, out-worked, or out-willed. And notice what undid me in that square. Not the loss. Being offered help. “What do you need first” is the most destabilizing question you can ask a person built like me, because it presumes need.

I think that is why the tears came then and not before. Something in me knew the paperwork was gone and that I was going to have to be received instead of verified.

Which is, as near as I can tell, what belonging is. Not being recognized. Being taken in without papers.

I got a new passport eventually. It sits in a drawer. Ten years on, the thing I remember from that week is not the document or the loss or the inconvenience of replacing a life’s worth of chargers. It is a laugh over the roof of an emptied car, and strangers in a language I was mangling, asking me what I needed first.

A companion reflection sheet for this post: What the Passport Couldn’t Prove (PDF).

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim Vaive and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ, where they work with leaders and seekers worldwide in coaching, training, and spiritual direction. Jim is a Master Certified Coach (ICF), a certified spiritual director, and a certified Narrative Enneagram teacher. Dr. Lynette Vaive is a Professional Certified Coach, a certified spiritual director, and a certified Narrative Enneagram teacher; her doctoral research is the scholarly foundation of the Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) framework. Together they write The Mystical Seeker on Substack and are co-authoring a book on SEQ. Reach them at jim@spiritofeq.com and lynette@spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Parker J. Palmer, Let Your Life Speak: Listening for the Voice of Vocation (Jossey-Bass, 2000), 2–3.

Richard Rohr, “Our Life’s Call,” Daily Meditations, Center for Action and Contemplation, 13 November 2026, cac.org/daily-meditations/our-lifes-call. The closing passage quoted here is adapted from Rohr’s Adam’s Return: The Five Promises of Male Initiation (Crossroad, 2004), 60–61.

© 2026 Spirit of EQ

It Isn’t Confusion. It’s Exhaustion.

In October of 2024 I set up a jeweller’s bench.

Not as a hobby. As a business — Jim’s Jewelry by Design. I made pieces people could hold while they were thinking: beads, knots, things with a weight to them. I bought the tools, learned the techniques, took the orders, did the books.

In May of this year I closed it.

I closed it because I did not have the time to do everything I needed to do. The writing and the coaching mattered more. They had to take center stage, and something had to go.

That is the tidy version. The honest one is less flattering. I am an Eight on the Enneagram, and here is what an Eight does: if I see something shiny lying in the sand, I rush over, pick it up, and turn it into a business. I have done it my whole life. A pest control company. A bread store. A jewellery bench. Each time the thing itself was real and worth doing. Each time the picking-up was automatic.

My focus is narrowing now, the way it does as you get older. And by the spring I was exhausted from keeping all the balls in the air.

That last word is what this post is about.

The thing we call confusion usually isn’t

I came across a piece recently by Cameron Trimble, a pastor and author, in Richard Rohr’s daily meditations from the Center for Action and Contemplation. She makes a distinction I have not stopped thinking about.

When people say they do not know what to do, they describe it as confusion. But confusion means you are missing information. Most of the time, she argues, what people are carrying is exhaustion — holding more than any one person should be holding.

Those two feel identical from the inside. They are not the same problem.

If it is confusion, more information helps. Get the numbers. Talk to someone who has done it.

If it is exhaustion, more information makes it worse. You are not short of input. You are overloaded, and every new consideration is one more thing to carry while you try to think.

I spent most of 2025 treating an exhaustion problem as a confusion problem. I read more, asked more people, made more lists about the bench — margins, time per piece, what it would take to make it work. I was very busy being thorough. None of it touched the actual thing, because the actual thing was that I had too much in my hands and no way to put any of it down.

The question was never is this a good business. It was how many things can one man in his seventies actually carry. No amount of research answers that one.

William James saw this in 1902

A brass compass resting on a rock in a field of tall grass at night, beneath a star-filled sky.

There is a passage in The Varieties of Religious Experience that I keep returning to, and it is not the one people usually quote.

James describes what he calls the field of consciousness — everything present to you at a given moment. It has a centre of interest, and around that centre the rest fades out to a margin “so faint that its limits are unassignable.” He compares it to a magnetic field, “inside of which our centre of energy turns like a compass-needle.”

Then he says this: “At other times, of drowsiness, illness, or fatigue, our fields may narrow almost to a point.”

Fatigue narrows the field. Not age, not weakness of character — fatigue. A tired person is not seeing less because they have become less; they are seeing less because the field itself has contracted, and from inside a contracted field there is no way to tell that anything is missing.

That is the whole trap. The exhausted person experiences their exhaustion as a failure of clarity, and reaches for more information — which requires more field, which they do not have.

Deciding and discerning are different jobs

Trimble’s second distinction is the one I had been circling for years without naming cleanly.

Deciding operates on a set of options. Someone has put three things on the table and your job is to pick the best one. Business is very good at this. There are frameworks, matrices, and people who will charge you a great deal to improve your hit rate.

Discerning happens before any of that. It asks whether the table is yours.

Here is why the difference costs money. A person who decides well clears options off the table quickly and confidently. That is a real strength. It is also exactly how you end up two years into something you never chose — because nobody asked whether they were the right options, and the speed of the deciding disguised the absence of the asking.

An Eight picking up something shiny from the sand is deciding, and deciding well. The business will probably work. The question nobody asks at that moment is whether it was his to pick up.

Trimble’s word for what people are actually after is attunement rather than certainty. Flatter version: most people chasing certainty want a guarantee about the outcome. What is available is a better read on what the situation is asking of you. Different purchases, and only one of them is for sale.

The in-between is not wasted time

One more thing from her piece — a reframe of a very old story.

A people leave one place and spend a long stretch in the desert before arriving anywhere. The usual reading of that stretch is dead time: a gap between the real chapters, to be endured.

The rabbinic reading she points to is the opposite. The time in between is not the delay before the thing happens. It is where they stopped being one kind of people and became another. They walked in carrying the habits of the place they had left — fear, scarcity, waiting to be told. Changing their location was the easy part. Changing that is what the years were for.

Out of the desert and into an ordinary working life: a transition is not the empty bit between two chapters. It is where you get re-made. Spend it entirely on getting out of it and you arrive as the same person who went in, which is generally how people make the same mistake in a new setting.

I have done that. Twice, at least.

And in that story nobody gets a map. They get a day’s food at a time — enough for today, nothing banked, no visibility past tomorrow. Her point, and mine: that is not a failure of provision. It is a description of how this works. You get enough for the next step, and the next step is enough.

For anyone who plans for a living that is uncomfortable. I ran a company for thirty-eight years on five-year horizons. But look at what the alternative demands: before you can act, you need a picture of an outcome several years out that nobody can honestly give you — and while you wait for it you do nothing, and call the nothing prudence.

What Insight actually is

This is the third domain of spiritual emotional intelligence, and the first two did the groundwork.

Awareness established that your own account of yourself is unreliable. Belonging asked who you are actually among, and whether a person can be among you with nothing to offer.

Insight is what becomes possible once those are in place. Not choose better between the things in front of me. Something narrower: work out which of them is mine.

Three questions, in order. Ten minutes.

One. Is this confusion or exhaustion? If you cannot name three specific facts you are missing, it is exhaustion. Stop researching. Your field has narrowed and no amount of reading will widen it.

Two. Who put these options on the table? If it is anyone but you, you are deciding rather than discerning, and the real work is upstream of the choice you think you are making.

Three. What is the next step, as against the plan? Not the strategy. The one thing you could do this week that you would not regret however the rest turns out.

That third question is most of it. Most people can answer it immediately and then refuse to act on it, because it feels too small to be the answer.

It is the answer. It is just small.

The bench

I still have it.

I have not decided what it is yet — whether it becomes a practice without being a business, or goes to someone who will use it better than I did. And for the first time in my life, not knowing by the end of the month does not feel like a failure of planning.

Enough for the next step turns out to be enough.

Post 3 of 3 on the domains of spiritual emotional intelligence. Part 1: The Last One to Know — Awareness. Part 2: What Do You Need First? — Belonging.

Peace and every good.

A companion workbook for this post: Is This Mine to Carry? (PDF).

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources and credits

The distinctions between confusion and exhaustion, deciding and discerning, and the reading of the wilderness years are drawn from a piece by Cameron Trimble, pastor and author, published in the Center for Action and Contemplation’s Daily Meditations (Richard Rohr). The applications to business and to my own decisions are mine, not hers.

William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), Lecture X. The passage on the field of consciousness and its narrowing “at other times, of drowsiness, illness, or fatigue” is quoted from that lecture.

What Do You Need First?

In September of 2016 we landed in Florence with everything we owned for the next ten days in the back of a rental car.

We were there for a Six Seconds Master Class — emotional intelligence practitioners from around the world, at a castle in Tuscany about ninety minutes out of the city. At the airport we picked up a woman we had never met, a Six Seconds colleague working out of Dubai who needed a ride. Canadian originally. Talkative in a way I was in no condition for after six hours of time difference.

We stopped in a village to eat. Busy square, cars everywhere, a small restaurant up a flight of stairs where the owner greeted us in English and talked us into the local red.

A restaurant table set for dinner in warm lamplight, with a carafe of red wine, two glasses, white flowers and a lit candle.

When we came back, every other car in that square was gone, and Lynette’s jacket was hanging out of a broken rear window.

They had used it to cover the hole. Suitcases, backpacks, computers, iPads — all of it. We stood on opposite sides of the car, looked at each other over the roof, and started laughing.

And my passport

It took a while for that one to land.

The clothes were an inconvenience. The computers were expensive. The passport was something else, and I did not have words for it that afternoon.

In a foreign country, that document is not a travel convenience. It is the only thing you carry that says who you are. Without it I could not prove my name, my nationality, my right to be standing where I was standing, or my ability to go home. Every other claim I had on the world — the company I had built, the work I did, the people who knew me — was eleven hundred miles away and completely unavailable.

I had my wife and the clothes I was wearing. That was the whole of my identity for the rest of that week.

We were in a liminal space from that point on, and I do not use that phrase loosely. There was the navigation of the loss itself, in another language. And underneath it, something I had not had to think about in decades: we had to work out how to fit in, where to fit in, and how to do it without any of the usual equipment.

That is a different experience from going to Italy on holiday. On holiday you are a visitor with a return ticket, and the question of whether you fit never comes up, because you are not trying to.

We were trying to.

Three things happened, and only one of them was kind

A policeman. I tried to explain to a local officer, in sign language, that our car had been emptied. He understood enough to send us back to Florence to file a report. Procedural. No warmth required, and none given.

A document we could not read. At the station the shared language turned out to be bad French, between our friend from Dubai and the officer. Lynette signed a theft report in Italian with no idea what it said. Her words for it, in her chapter of our book, are that she was entirely at the mercy of two people she had met only that day.

Then I got lost looking for parking and had to text and ask where they were, which was my contribution to the afternoon.

And whoever broke the window. That square was full of people. Someone put the glass through on a parked car in daylight and nobody stopped them.

I want that third one in here, because the comfortable version of this story is people are good. People are various. Belonging is not a claim about human nature. It is about what particular people do when you can do nothing for them.

The question

Two colleagues from the Six Seconds community in Italy — Tomasso and Ilaria — heard what had happened and texted to find out where we were. We asked them to meet us at the rental place, where we were swapping a car with a hole in it and paying for the hole.

They arrived. And their first question was not how are you, and it was not let us know if you need anything.

It was: what do you need first?

And I cried.

I will leave that where it is rather than dress it up. I was in my sixties. I had built a company with several hundred people in it and the words failure is not an option painted above the door. I had spent the whole day being competent at a robbery — sign language with police, a report I could not read, a rental counter, a wife to get to a castle. I had not come close to losing it once.

Then two people I barely knew asked me a question I could answer, and I could not hold it.

I have had nine years to think about why, and the best I can do is this: for most of that day I had been a problem being processed. A case number, a damaged vehicle, a man gesturing at a policeman. What do you need first was the first moment anyone had treated me as a person who still had needs rather than a situation requiring management. It arrived about four hours after I had stopped being able to prove who I was.

Then they drove us to an electronics shop and spoke Italian while we stood and watched, and we came out with phone chargers and a hair dryer with the right voltage for Lynette. Then they took us to a restaurant, got us a table in a sheltered corner, and ordered for us — because they had worked out we did not have another round of language in us that day.

Why that question and not the other one

Let me know if you need anything sounds generous and does almost nothing, because it hands the work back to the person who is already carrying too much. They have to work out what they need, decide whether it is fair to ask, find the words, and risk the no. Most people, at their lowest, will simply say they are fine.

What do you need first does the opposite. It assumes there is a list. It assumes the list is long. It asks for one item. And it can be answered in four seconds by somebody standing in a car park with nothing.

That is not a warmer way of saying the same thing. It is a different thing, and the difference is who does the work.

If you lead people, this is the single most portable thing in this post. The next time someone on your team is underwater, do not offer to help. Ask them what they need first.

Gentle while we got it wrong

Here is what I remember most clearly, and it took me years to understand it.

We messed up the language. We messed up the customs. We turned up at the wrong hours, mispronounced everything, misread how things were done — and the Italians we met were gentle with us the entire time.

Not patient the way people are patient with a nuisance. Gentle. The restaurant owner who switched to English unasked. Tomasso and Ilaria ordering our dinner. The people at the training who told us where the shops were and then took us — three separate trips before we were dressed again. A waitress at the end of that week who kept her restaurant open past closing for our first wedding anniversary, put American music on, and made us a meal we still talk about. We ran into her in the square afterwards and met her son.

None of them were buying anything from us. We had nothing to trade, no standing, and in my case no document proving I was anyone at all — and we were welcomed anyway.

That is belonging, and it is worth being exact about why. Identity is what you can prove. Belonging is what happens when you cannot prove anything and are received regardless.

Most organizations never find out which one they are running on, because almost nobody in them is ever that exposed. What gets measured is contribution — so people quietly conclude that their standing is their usefulness. That holds up fine until the week they have nothing. Then they find out what they actually had.

The part I did not know at the time

Near the end of the week we asked Josh Freedman, who runs Six Seconds, about getting more involved. He told us he had been watching how we handled it.

That conversation is why the SEQ assessment exists. The framework this series is about came out of a week in which I had no passport, no luggage and no language, and was carried by people who owed me nothing.

I did not know I was being watched. Nobody does. Worth sitting with, if you lead anything: people are deciding whether you belong with them based on what you are like when it has gone wrong — and no one is going to tell you they are deciding.

Post 2 of 3 on the domains of spiritual emotional intelligence. Part 1: The Last One to Know — Awareness. Next: It Isn’t Confusion, It’s Exhaustion — Insight.

Peace and every good.

A companion workbook for this post: Who Gets to Arrive With Nothing (PDF).

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources and credits

The events of September 2016 are told more fully in Dr. Lynette Vaive’s Chapter 1 of our forthcoming book on Spiritual Emotional Intelligence. Her account is the source for the sequence of that afternoon and for her own words about signing the theft report.

Tomasso and Ilaria are named with thanks, and with permission.

The Last One to Know

I was looking at my own blog archive last week. Six titles in a column, going back about six weeks.

Back to the Log. Ninety Trucks, Ninety Driveways. The Pitcher We Are Becoming. The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With. The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else. The Problem Was Never Being Right.

Six subjects. Six weeks. And reading them in a row, I realized I had written the same post six times without noticing.

A partly carved wooden head on a workbench, seen from behind so its face is turned away, with chisels beside it and sunrise over hills through the studio window.

He would set it down, walk out of the studio, and come back the next morning to look at it the way a stranger would.

What surprised me was that there was a thread emerging for me where I had not seen one before. Six separate things I thought I was writing about, and one thing I was actually writing about.

The same shape underneath

Every one of them has the same shape.

Something was going on in me. I had an explanation for what was going on in me. The two were not the same thing — and I was the only person in the room who couldn’t tell.

In The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With, the line was failure is not an option. I experienced that as discipline. The people working for me experienced it as pressure they couldn’t put down. Most of them went on to successful lives in spite of me. A few are still bitter, and they have a right to be.

In The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else, a client went quiet on me and my first thought was what did I do. I thought I was being accountable. I was being cruel in a way I would never have been to a stranger.

In The Problem Was Never Being Right, I watched someone early in their coaching and thought, that person should not be a coach. I thought I was exercising discernment. I was protecting a position.

And Back to the Log is the one about the log itself — my dad bringing a piece of wood out of the forest and starting there, taking it back when the slope of a cheek wasn’t right. That post was supposed to be about writing. It wasn’t.

The reasonable person in the story

Here is the part worth sitting with.

In none of those was I confused about myself. I wasn’t walking around wondering what my problem was. I had an answer ready. Discipline. Accountability. Discernment. High standards.

The answers were wrong, and they were wrong in one consistent direction: every single explanation made me the reasonable person in the story.

That is not a character flaw. That is how the equipment works.

There is a piece of research I keep coming back to. In 1988 two researchers named Harris and Schaubroeck pooled every study they could find comparing how people rate their own job performance against how their peers and their supervisors rate them.

Peers and supervisors agreed with each other at .62 — strong agreement, two independent groups of people seeing roughly the same person.

Your own rating agreed with your supervisor’s at .35. With your peers’, at .36.

Read that again. The people around you agree with each other about you nearly twice as much as either of them agrees with you.

You are not in the conversation about who you are. You are the subject of it.

Why emotional intelligence doesn’t reach this

Emotional intelligence, as most people learn it, teaches you to name what you feel. That is real work, and most of us genuinely cannot do it. Naming the feeling is worth every hour it takes.

But look back at those four failures. Not one of them was a failure of naming.

I could have told you I was frustrated with that coach. I could have told you exactly what the anxiety felt like when the client went quiet. The feeling was available to me the whole time. The feeling was never the problem.

The problem was the story I had built on top of the feeling — and the story was invisible precisely because I was standing inside it.

That is the gap. And that gap is the first domain of what Lynette and I call spiritual emotional intelligence: Awareness.

Self-awareness asks: what am I feeling?

Awareness asks: what is this feeling pointing at, and what is it protecting?

The second question is harder, because it assumes something uncomfortable — that you are not a reliable narrator of yourself. Not because you are dishonest. Because nobody is. The instrument you would use to check is the same instrument that generated the story.

So what do you actually do

A weathered wooden signpost reading Forward with an arrow, beside a dirt path winding away through golden hills at sunrise.

Three things you can do. None of them is thinking harder about yourself.

Three things.

Use the Enneagram as a prediction, not a label. Most people treat their number as a description of who they are. It is more useful as advance warning about which story you will reach for when you are squeezed. Mine always reaches for the competent one. Knowing that does not stop it. It does mean I can catch it about forty seconds sooner than I used to.

Ask a narrower question than you want to ask. “How am I doing?” gets you nothing, because nobody answers it honestly. The question worth asking is: what is it like to be on the other side of me when I am under pressure? It is specific enough that people can answer, and uncomfortable enough that the answer is usually real. If you want to find your own gap, that question will get there faster than a year of journaling.

Turn the examen sideways. End of the day, two questions instead of the usual ones. Where today did I feel most like myself? Where today was I performing? You do not have to do anything with the answers for a while. Just notice that there is a gap, and that the gap is always in the same place.

Back to the log

A partly carved wooden head seen from the side on a workbench, carving chisels and wood shavings in the foreground, bare winter trees through the window behind.

Not with the piece — he didn’t have the piece yet. With the log.

My dad would carry a log out of the woods and start there. Not with the piece — he did not have the piece yet. With the log. He would work the slope of a cheek for days and then take the whole thing back and begin again.

I used to think that was perfectionism. I do not think that anymore.

I think he knew he could not trust his own eye at close range. So he would set it down, walk out of the studio, come back the next morning and look at it the way a stranger would. That is not perfectionism. That is a man building a workaround for a limitation he had the sense to admit.

You cannot see your own face. You can only see what it does to the room.

Six posts in six weeks, and I was the last one to know what I was writing about.


Take this further

Finding the Story You Are Standing Inside is a free four-part workbook built on this post — an inventory of four incidents, the direction your explanations bend, the narrow question to put to two people, and the examen turned sideways. Download the workbook (PDF).

Post 1 of 3 on the domains of spiritual emotional intelligence. Next: Belonging — ninety identical trucks and ninety different lives. Then: Insight — what is actually mine to do.

Peace and every good.


About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Harris, M. M., & Schaubroeck, J. (1988). A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 43–62. doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.1988.tb00631.x — self–supervisor ρ = .35, self–peer .36, peer–supervisor .62.

Fleenor, J., Smither, J., Atwater, L., Braddy, P., & Sturm, R. E. (2010). Self-other rating agreement in leadership: A review. The Leadership Quarterly, 21(6), 1005–1034 — the standard review of this literature, for readers who want more.

Are You Thirsty?

This is the last of three from Academy for Spiritual Formation #43, a program of The Upper Room. Our faculty presenter for session five of eight was Dr. Heidi A. Miller, associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, teaching on prayer and the art of discernment. Part one was about the word just. Part two was about the body. This one is about standing up when the ground will not hold still.

Friday was the last morning, and she opened by telling us the ground was shaking.

“The very ground we stand on is shaking.” Then she said it again, the way she did with the lines that mattered.

She told us about a friend caught in an earthquake in another country, running out of a building. “We’d put our foot down, and then the ground would shift, and we’d put it down and be at another spot than where we aimed.” The most disorienting thing she had ever been through — and notice that the disorienting part was not the shaking. It was arriving somewhere you had not aimed.

I know that feeling. When I had my heart attack twelve years ago, there was a violent earthquake in what I thought was true, and putting my foot down did not change that.

Twelve years later, in a three-minute prayer on a Wednesday morning in that same room, the same body said the same thing to me much more quietly.

Then she had us do the simplest exercise of the week.

A blessing of the senses

Five things you can see. Take your time with them. Then touch your eyes, and let the Spirit tend your sight.

Four things you can touch. Open your hands, and let the Spirit tend your touch.

Three things you can hear. Touch your ears.

Two things you can smell. Touch your nostrils.

One thing you can taste — she had put things out on the tables beforehand so that everyone would have something. Touch your mouth.

Amen.

If you have done trauma work, or sat in a counselor’s office, you have met 5-4-3-2-1 before. What she had done was marry it to something much older: the blessing of the senses given to catechumens as they begin, formalized in the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults after Vatican II. She called that kind of borrowing “a migration of meaning,” and her point was that all of us are catechumens — still being taught toward something, over and over.

“When nothing makes sense, grounding our discernment back into our senses helps. It also helps prevent longer trauma.”

Then she walked us through how much of the gospel runs on the senses. Jesus making spittle out of mud. Thomas, touch my side. Cooking fish over a fire for the disciples after the resurrection — and she noted that it was by a fire that Peter denied him, and by a fire that Jesus came back for him. The woman with the alabaster jar down at his feet, and the whole room filling with that perfume.

Soil kin

Then she gave us the wordplay I wrote down twice.

Adamah is the Hebrew word for soil. Adam is human. Same root. Humus. Human.

“We are soil kin,” she said. “Earthlings.”

Ashes to ashes and dust to dust comes straight out of that passage — which means it is not first a sentence about death. It is a sentence about where we are from.

And the day before, she had made the point that has stayed with me longest. When God creates in Genesis 2, God’s posture is down in the dirt. The serpent’s posture is up in a tree, looking down. One of those is a God who has made himself available to be wounded.

She looked up the etymology of vulnerable while she was preparing. It means the capacity to be wounded. “I fought that,” she admitted. “I just kept going — it’s got to be the vastness of God. Got to be. And I kept looking at it and it was like: that is not the God being presented here.”

Nephesh is a verb

Then she turned it into an obligation, which I did not see coming.

Nephesh — life, breath, fullness of being — is not only a noun. In Exodus it is a verb. God rested on the seventh day and was re-nefeshed.

And look at how the commandment extends it. Six days you shall do your work, but on the seventh you shall rest — so that your ox and your donkey may have relief, and your home-born slave and the resident alien may be refreshed. Re-nefeshed.

Rest is not a personal wellness item. In that text, rest is something you owe your neighbor, your worker, the stranger in your house, and your animals.

Which produces her question, and it is the one I carried home from the whole week: who is not allowed to rest in our culture?

She pointed at Isaiah confronting people who sat in worship while the people they had hired worked straight through with no re-nefeshing at all. “See — that jug of being just? It’s not for the other person. We’re not getting a just pour.”

And then she described, with uncomfortable accuracy, what every organization does when things get hard. “Just work harder. Staff gets cut in half. Now you do all the rest of the jobs the staff had before, on half the people, and do it all the same. More should, ought, must, quicker, more efficient. So we buy more planners that are kind of nice and pretty. And we work with them for three weeks and it doesn’t work. And we wonder what’s wrong with us — if I was only better.”

I ran a company with ninety trucks. The crews took them home overnight, which meant ninety driveways across central Ohio with a black-and-gold truck parked in them, which meant the work sat outside ninety houses every night. I called that efficiency. I built it. I am the one who decided who got to rest.

I have said things close to this in other pieces, so I will not pretend it is a new discovery. What started to change my perspective was learning what it means to be human. Yes, we have to work. Yes, we have to be productive. But pushing and pushing and pushing to get a ten or twelve percent growth, at the expense of health and happiness — I don’t know. I am still not sure I have the answer.

The prayer he got wrong

She told us about a large congregation in Harrisonburg, and a very seasoned leader near retirement who stood up in front of everyone and said: I used to pray that God would keep us from what threatens us around us.

She was careful here. Prayers of protection are real and good — traveling mercies, the breastplate prayers. But when protection becomes the primal prayer of a church, proximity turns into something to be defended against rather than entered.

And this man said, in front of that whole congregation: I got the prayer wrong.

The prayer he had come to instead was: God, what are you doing in this neighborhood that we need to join?

She gave us the other half of it from James Baldwin, whom she came back to more than once across the week — that for white people racism is “a corrosive spiritual bondage,” and that avoiding another person’s humanity erases neither the kinship nor the guilt of having violated it. Her own extension of it was blunt: no amount of claiming that someone else is not human makes the rest of us more human. “I too am an it that is expendable.”

Armor protects. That is what it is for. And then the question becomes the one she asked next: what happens when we become the armor?

Many to one

So what do you do, when the ground is moving and the warning lights are on everywhere at once and your brain wants to go in every direction? Her own impulse, she said, is either to curl up in sackcloth and ashes or go screaming through the streets like a prophet. “You really get a sense for prophets.”

Her practice for it is moving from the many to the one.

  1. Notice the many. She will sometimes have people write the crowding things on slips of paper and set them all around themselves on the floor, because the body understands a pile better than it understands a list. What is crowding me?
  2. Go to a window, or outside, and do a wide-lens scan of the horizon. Slowly. Distance, sky, trees. Wait, and notice the shift in your body.
  3. Choose one gift. A leaf. A blade of grass. An ant crossing a stone. One. Wait with it — “it tells you a different story.”
  4. Go back to the many, and ask to see it with a new lens.

She tied this to the woman with the hemorrhage, who came up behind Jesus in a crowd that was pressing on him from every side, and touched the edge of his cloak. Peter’s line is essentially that everyone is touching you. And in all that noise, Jesus stopped and asked: who touched me? Not who is shouting. Who touched me.

“It’s like the crowd’s there, and all of a sudden — something touched me here that I’m to pick up.”

Then honor the one.

Are you thirsty?

An older man wrapped in a wool shawl drinks from a clay cup on a stone wall above the hills at sunrise, a large two-handled jug beside him.
Just, as we learned on the first morning of the week, is a pitcher. The measure of the pour.

She closed the week with a small story, and I am closing with it too, because it is the whole week in a single question.

A librarian came through two years of spiritual direction training. Part of that training was about being a director in your own neighborhood — the informal version, a way of being rather than an appointment. She said that a lot of the people who come into her library are unhoused, and she was beginning to see them differently. She also volunteered at a farmers market, handing out water.

“I used to just say: do you want some water?”

After two years, she said, I ask a different question.

Are you thirsty?

That is it. One word different, and a transaction becomes a person.

Gerard Manley Hopkins has the line for it, and Dr. Heidi left it up on her last slide. What I do is me: for that I came. And then: the just man justices.

Just, as we learned on the first morning of the week, is a pitcher. The measure of the pour.

And by Friday it was a verb.


Take this further

Many to One is a free reflection sheet carrying the blessing of the senses and the many-to-one practice, with eight questions and an invitation for the week. Download the reflection sheet (PDF).

Part 3 of 3. Part 1: Just — the word, the pitcher, and where the story starts. Part 2: presence, the body, and why you cannot achieve it.

Peace and every good.


With gratitude to Dr. Heidi A. Miller

Everything of substance in this post is hers. The blessing of the senses and its adaptation from the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults, the adamah and adam wordplay, the reading of nephesh as a verb and of rest as something owed to a neighbor, the question of who is not allowed to rest, the story of the leader who said he got the prayer wrong, the many-to-one practice, the Hopkins poem, and the librarian’s question — all of it came from her sessions at Academy #43, session five, October 2026. The quotations are drawn from recordings of those sessions. What is mine is only what it did to me.

Dr. Miller is associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, where she directs the Doctor of Ministry program.

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Dr. Heidi A. Miller, “Prayer and the Art of Discernment,” The Academy for Spiritual Formation #43, session five, October 2026 (The Upper Room). Quotations drawn from session recordings.

Gerard Manley Hopkins, “As Kingfishers Catch Fire” (public domain). Dr. Miller noted that she had taken a small liberty with inclusive language in the closing lines as she read them.

James Baldwin — quoted by Dr. Miller across several sessions on racism as a corrosive spiritual bondage and on what dehumanizing does to the one who does it.

Jonathan Sacks on mishpat and tzedakah — retributive and distributive justice — referenced in her session on nuancing what justice means.

Resmaa Menakem, My Grandmother’s Hands (Central Recovery Press, 2017), and Martin Luther King Jr., Where Do We Go From Here: Chaos or Community? — both recommended from the front of the room.

I Would Have Cleaned the Window

This is part two of three from Academy for Spiritual Formation #43, a program of The Upper Room. Our faculty presenter for session five of eight was Dr. Heidi A. Miller, associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, teaching on prayer and the art of discernment. Part one was about the word just. This one is about the body.

Wednesday morning, Dr. Heidi told us to find a spot.

Stand if you want. Sit on the floor. Lie down on the floor if that is what works. If you need to turn away from me so it does not feel like anyone is looking at you, turn away — there is a spot behind the piano that is perfect.

Then she gave us three minutes and this:

Acknowledge the gift of your body. Our body is our friend. Notice where you are carrying tension, or pain. What does your body want you to know? And in time, if it feels comfortable, take your hand and touch that part. Remind that part of your body of belovedness. Then find the rhythm of your breath right there. Breathe in belovedness. Pause. Breathe out the tension.

When I sank down into the center of my body, I found that I loved it, and that I knew what was best for it, and I felt it telling me that I was not hearing it.

This may sound like a strange thing to come out of a three-minute prayer, but I stopped eating gluten and sugar. I am slowly feeling different. The brain fog is lifting.

She called it a body awareness prayer, and she was explicit about why she kept starting us there. “The locus of discernment is here,” she said — not in the head. “Our bodies are a locale of discernment.” We make sense of our lives through our bodies and through stories, “and mostly, it’s embodied stories when you put that together.”

Then she told us about her grandmother’s window.

The imprint of presence

Her mother was an English child of the Second World War, evacuated out of London, raised under Victorian rules in a house with an anxious mother who had reason to be anxious. What she learned was that you tidy up. Whatever you touch, you leave no trace of having touched it.

She married an American, and his parents sponsored her, and they called her daughter. Not daughter-in-law. Daughter. And they put their own son in his place when they saw him startle her once as a joke: You don’t ever do that again. Do you hear me? You don’t do that to my daughter.

The grandmother’s name was Myrtle. Eighth-grade education, Southern Baptist, and when the Spirit moved her she would just go whoop.

One day the family was packing up to leave after a week, and there was a plate glass window the kids had been pressing their hands against all week, watching to see who was coming up the road. Heidi’s mother said: Mama Myrtle, let me wipe that down before we go.

And Myrtle said: Now, Wendy, don’t you clean that window. I’m going to get so much joy looking at all those fingerprints for weeks and weeks and weeks.

“The imprint of presence,” Heidi said, “can be everywhere.”

Her mother learned it from Myrtle and passed it down. When Heidi was three or four and wanted to be in the kitchen, her mother started her on thumbprint cookies — press your thumb in, again and again, then fill the dent with jam. Heidi complained that her mother was faster at it. Her mother said: someday, when you teach someone how to make cookies, you will go faster too.

And when her brother tore his teddy bear doing something he knew he should not have, and brought it to their mother teary, braced to be scolded — she cleared off the kitchen table, carried a lamp over, laid out a handkerchief, set the bear down on it and said, It’s okay. We’re going to take care of this bear. She built an operating room in the kitchen, with the light, and stitched it up while he watched.

At her celebration of life, his words for it were: she tilted the whole universe in love toward me.

I would have cleaned the window

A galvanized bucket and a folded cloth on a wooden table in front of a spotless window, with two children running across a sunlit lawn outside.
The glass is clean, the cloth is folded, and the children are outside. This was the part I was always good at.

I sat there doing the arithmetic on myself.

I would have cleaned the window. Not out of cruelty — out of the thing I called responsibility. For thirty-eight years I ran a company with failure is not an option painted above the door. I worked constantly. I very seldom took a break, and when I did, I was already thinking about the next job and the next idea. There were no fingerprints left anywhere, because I wiped them, and the people around me learned to wipe theirs too.

If I can be totally honest in this moment: I do not know if I could, or would, do the same things in business that I did before. Sometimes I feel the cost was too high for the outcome — and the outcome, of course, was not money.

Why you cannot achieve it

Here is the part that got me, and it got me because she said it about herself first.

“I’m a three on the Enneagram,” she told the room. The achiever. Checklists, tasks, the completion of tasks. “But this approach does not work with being present.” And then: “Presence is not something to be achieved. Presence is a way of being.” And then, dryly: “That’s super hard for a three.”

I am an Eight, not a Three, but the machinery is close enough. Hand me presence as a goal and I will go at it the way I went at everything, and the going at it is exactly what forecloses it.

She had two names for what gets in the way.

The first she borrowed and renamed. Jacques Ellul wrote about the technological bluff — the premise that we are all intimate now, all accessible, all reachable at once. She calls it presence bluffing. “The more accessible we are to everybody else all the time, the less present we can really even be.” Her example was counting televisions in a restaurant. She got to twenty without turning her head.

The second was an Armani suit jacket.

A friend of hers was going through a mediated divorce — one day to settle everything, a warm Virginia day, both of them working hard at it, real credit to both. She had dressed in layers and was peeling them off as the hours went on. He wore an Armani jacket, and he wanted her to know it, and he wanted the mediator to know it. The room got hotter. He rolled his trouser legs inside out all the way up to his hips rather than take off that jacket.

When the group was telling the story afterward, Heidi said: “I wonder what the headlines in the heavens read. Man thinks he has Armani, but Armani has man.”

And then, immediately, on herself: “As soon as I say that, I can’t escape it either. I think I have that — but that has me.”

That, she said, is as old as Genesis 3. The strangest thing in that story is that the serpent lures them into wanting to possess what they already have. Everything is given. Blessed, abundant, playful, full, theirs. And the lure is: if you have it, you will be like God. So they ate a different story, in their own bodies, over food. And the moment they had it, it had them.

Possession is what keeps us from presence. It keeps us chasing. But the body already knows. Before Adam and Eve could say a word, their bodies knew they were naked.

The question underneath

She asked one more thing I have not been able to put down.

Why is presence so hard? Because being present means being present to your pain. And because being present means admitting you are mortal.

“If I don’t have to be present, I don’t have to grieve,” she said. “Or I can pretend I don’t have to grieve. If I keep busy, if I do more, if I go get more, I don’t have to grieve the hefty losses I’ve encountered. I don’t have to grieve that I too am mortal.”

I am seventy-four years old. I have been busy my whole adult life. I would rather not look too hard at the overlap between those two sentences.

The counterweight she offered is a word. Nephesh — life, breath, fullness of being. And it is not only a noun. In Exodus, God rested on the seventh day and was re-nefeshed. Rest is built into the rhythm before anything else happens — and there was evening, and there was morning, the first day. It starts with the rest.

She told us her mother confronted her about this once. Heidi said, I can’t, I’ve got too much to do.

Her mother said: well, then, you are better than God.

What? I don’t think I’m better than God.

Well, clearly you do. Because God rested, and you think you don’t have to.

Who told you

In Genesis 3, God comes walking in the garden at the time of the evening breeze, and they hide in the very creation they were meant to commune with. And when God finds them, Heidi pointed out, God does not condemn them. God asks a question.

Who told you you were naked?

“God could well have asked,” she said, “who told you you were not beloved and free already?”

Then she had someone act out Psalm 23. One volunteer, playing God, no lines — just walk around the room and set a table beside each person. You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies. Watch her do it. Watch the divine table setter set it.

And then she gave us a permission I did not expect. You may need to watch from across the room. You can say: not closer, not right now — I will be over here, you go ahead. You can say, I would like to be in the next room. And she will say: all right. I will set the table. It’s okay.

That is not a technique. That is somebody who understands that presence cannot be forced — including by you, on yourself.

I keep coming back to Myrtle at that window, deciding that fingerprints were not a mess.

For a man who spent four decades wiping glass, that is an entire theology in one sentence.


Take this further

The Imprint of Presence is a free reflection sheet built around the body awareness prayer Dr. Miller gave us, with eight questions and an invitation for the week. Download the reflection sheet (PDF).

Part 2 of 3. Part 1: Just — the word, the pitcher, and where the story starts. Part 3: being grounded when the ground is moving.

Peace and every good.


With gratitude to Dr. Heidi A. Miller

Everything of substance in this post is hers. The body awareness prayer, the story of her grandmother’s window and the thumbprint cookies and the teddy bear, the naming of presence bluffing, the Armani observation, the reading of Genesis 2 and 3, the enacted Psalm 23 and the permission to watch from a distance — all of it came from her sessions at Academy #43, session five, October 2026. The quotations are drawn from recordings of those sessions. What is mine is only what it did to me.

Dr. Miller is associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, where she directs the Doctor of Ministry program.

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Dr. Heidi A. Miller, “Prayer and the Art of Discernment,” The Academy for Spiritual Formation #43, session five, October 2026 (The Upper Room). Quotations drawn from session recordings.

Jacques Ellul, The Technological Bluff (Eerdmans, 1990) — the source of the phrase Dr. Miller adapts into “presence bluffing.”

Bessel van der Kolk, The Body Keeps the Score (Viking, 2014) — referenced in her sessions on the body as a place of knowing.

The Pitcher We Are Becoming

THE ACADEMY SERIES  ·  PART 1 OF 3

The Pitcher We Are Becoming

I had been on both sides of that word my whole life and never once noticed it had two.

The Academy for Spiritual Formation is a program of The Upper Room. I am part of Academy #43, and this past week was session five of eight. One of our faculty presenters for the week was Dr. Heidi A. Miller, associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, teaching on prayer and the art of discernment.

I walked into the room not knowing what to expect, and Dr. Heidi was standing there.

Here was this woman with a wonderfully big smile, going around introducing herself to everyone in the room. No pretense. No guile. Just pure personhood — approachable and loving.

By the end of the week she had taken a word I have said ten thousand times without once hearing it, turned it over, and handed it back to me as something I am supposed to become.

The word is just.

She started with an electrician

He had been working for weeks in her brother and sister-in-law’s house, redoing all the wiring after a move. He was from the Czech Republic. At some point they started asking him about himself — who he was, how he was, what he liked to cook. It turned out he loved cooking, and he told them about the spices he put together, the ones he had brought over with him, the aromas of them. Then he started bringing them food.

And he told them: you’re different, because you treat me like I’m human. I’m somebody.

Most of our exchanges are transactions. I know this from thirty years of running a company. I needed the plumbing done, so I heard the plumber. Heidi was careful to say that plumbers and electricians are real gifts, true gifts — the problem isn’t the trade, it’s that the whole of a person gets compressed into what I can get from them. “Rather than the transaction,” she said, “we begin to be seen as human.”

What struck me was that it cost her family nothing. They asked him what he liked to cook. That was the whole intervention. And a man who had been in their house for weeks as a function suddenly became a person with a country and a kitchen and something to give.

A word we use to diminish

That is where she turned to the word.

Just is a word we use to diminish. It’s just me calling. It’s just a passing phase. It’s just in your head — the doctor said to the mother who knew something was wrong with her child. Merely. Only. Barely worth the breath it took. She said it the way you say a word you have been on the receiving end of.

And then she gave us where it comes from. Just traces back through old English and Latin to a juste — a pitcher. There are records of it in the British Isles journals of weights and measures: a vessel of about a gallon and a half, two handles, the thing people carried to be filled with ale or wine. It mattered because merchants kept quietly changing the size of their just so they could shortchange the villagers, and the fines for it were recorded almost daily. So the just became the measure. That’s just enough. That is so just. My just is full.

A pitcher that tells you whether the pour was honest.

“But what about us becoming the just?” she asked. “Us being the vessel. Us being the pitcher who learns to listen differently and pour out what is true.”

My first thought was: crap

Because I have always thought of myself as a just man. That is the word I would have used. In business, in my dealings with people, I was fair. I paid what I said I would pay. I did what I said I would do. The second definition — fair, equitable, guided by justice — I thought I had earned that one.

And then she told us about the merchants. How they quietly changed the size of their just so the pour came up short, and how the fines for it were being recorded almost every day.

Did I shortchange people?

Thirty years. Hundreds of employees. A thousand conversations where I was the one holding the pitcher and deciding what a fair pour looked like. I would like to believe the measure was honest every time. I am not sure I can.

And the other sense of the word came for me in the same breath. Did I ever say just let it be? Did I use that word to wave someone off — to close a conversation I did not want to have, to make a thing smaller than it was so I would not have to carry it?

I know the answer to that one.

I had been on both sides of that word my whole life and never once noticed it had two.

Where the story starts

Then she said the part I keep returning to. She asked where the story starts.

Most of us, she said, live from Genesis 3 forward. The fall, and then everything after.

“Notice where the story starts,” she said. “And notice what the hope of the story is — that I won’t go to hell.”

She brought in Brian McLaren’s observation that the hook which draws a person into Christianity is often the hook that has to keep bringing them back. Which means somebody has to keep making you feel worse about yourself in order to get you further in.

“That’s not where God begins,” she said. “The divine begins with creating. Again, and again, and again. And it’s rooted and dwells in belovedness.”

Original blessing. And God saw that it was good. And there was evening and there was morning. A rhythm, she said — a rhythm of rooting ourselves in belovedness again and again and again, because we do not stay rooted, and the going back is the practice.

She asked the room what the word belovedness evokes. People called it out. Unconditional. Embraced by Christ. Belonging. A gift. Mattering. Cherished. Acceptance.

And then she asked the harder one, which is the question I came home with: what keeps us from dwelling there?

Because something does. I have sat in rooms where every person could have given the right answer about being beloved and not one of us was living out of it on a Tuesday afternoon in traffic.

Longing at the back of the line

She got at it by having people act it out. One person in a chair — that’s you, the self. Someone standing behind, driving — that’s what’s driving you. Someone behind that, the spirit of it. And behind that, farther back than you would think to look, longing.

Lynette was called up to stand as longing.

I watched my wife take her place at the back of that line, farther from the chair than anything else in it, and something in me went quiet. It is one thing to hear that longing sits underneath everything driving us. It is another to see it acted out with someone you love standing in the part.

Then she layered in the God images, the negative ones people have carried — what are you doing, I’m coming to get you — and had them stand in front, between the person and everything else. Her point was plain enough once you saw it standing up in a room: how a person functions in the world is bound to their image of God, and most of us are working off images we never chose and never examined.

Becoming The Just Reflection Sheet

Spiritual, not religious

That is where something came loose for me.

I have been conflicted most of my adult life about what the right way is to lead a spiritual life. Spiritual — not religious. Those are not the same thing, and I have never been able to say cleanly why they aren’t.

The religious version always came with the starting point already handed to me. You are a sinner, here is the gap, here is the bridge, now pray after me. It worked on me when I was young, the way it works on everybody. But it never settled, and for fifty years I could not name what was unsettled about it.

This talk cleared it up. The problem was never that the religious version asked too much of me. The problem was where it starts the story. If I begin at Genesis 3, every practice I take up afterward is remedial — I am working my way back toward something I am told I lost. If I begin where she says God begins, in creating and in belovedness, then the practice is not a repair job. It is a return to what was already true.

That is the difference I could never articulate. Religion handed me a deficit to close. The spiritual life she was describing hands you a given to dwell in.

I am seventy-four years old. I would have liked to have that forty years ago. I will take it now.

The pitcher I would like to be becoming

What I came away with is not a technique. Heidi was careful about that all week — a spiritual practice is not the thing itself, it is what distills the thing. The purpose, she said, is that we become it. “I can become God’s prayer in the world. I can be a breath bearer instead of a breath taker.”

A breath bearer instead of a breath taker. A vessel instead of a word that means barely.

I wrote down my first impression of her before I knew any of this. I said she was just pure personhood. I meant it the way we all mean it — merely, simply, nothing more than that. But that isn’t what the word does. A just is a vessel, and the measure of it is whether the pour is honest.

She had been exactly that, standing in the doorway, before she said a word about it.

Just enough. My just is full.

That is the pitcher I would like to be becoming.

Part 1 of 3. Part 2: presence, the body, and why we cannot achieve it. Part 3: being grounded when the ground is moving.

Peace and every good.

 

With gratitude to Dr. Heidi A. Miller

Everything of substance in this post is hers. The teaching on just, the etymology of the pitcher, the Genesis 1 and 2 framing, the exercise that put longing at the back of the line, the phrase breath bearer instead of breath taker — all of it came from her sessions at Academy #43, session five, October 2026. The quotations are drawn from recordings of those sessions. What is mine is only what it did to me.

Dr. Miller is associate professor of spirituality and Christian ministry at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology, where she directs the Doctor of Ministry program.

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Dr. Heidi A. Miller, “Prayer and the Art of Discernment,” The Academy for Spiritual Formation #43, session five, October 2026 (The Upper Room). Quotations drawn from session recordings.

Brian D. McLaren on the entry point of Christian formation — a recurring theme across his work.

The Problem Was Never Being Right

The Problem Was Never Being Right

Believing your values are right is not the problem. The problem is when that belief buys you a higher place in the room.

My friend Ajené sent me a research paper last week with four words attached: Just sharing. Saddens me.

I should say plainly that my brain is not wired to absorb this kind of information the way it was intended. I read the methods section twice and understood it the second time about as well as the first. It took me a good while to sift through, and what I came away with is a surface reading at best.

But the surface was enough to stop me.

Five studies. Over a thousand people. The same finding every time.

When a group believes itself morally superior to another group, it begins to perceive the people in that other group as less than fully human. And that perception predicts aggression.

Hmmmmm.

It is not a study about bad actors

Here is what makes it land so hard.

This is not research about extremists, or ideologues, or people with something wrong with them. The researchers ran it on American conservatives and liberals and got the effect on both sides, independent of political orientation. They ran it in China on people who supported and opposed euthanasia. And then — this is the part I keep returning to — they ran it on groups that did not exist.

They gave people a meaningless picture test and told them they had a cognitive style called “Dusek” or “Tausig.” Invented words. Assigned at random, minutes earlier, on the basis of nothing at all. Then they told some of them their invented group was the more virtuous one.

It still happened. People began rating the other invented group as less human. And it predicted aggression toward them.

So this is not about history, or grievance, or the genuine wrongs that real groups have done to one another. Those make it worse, certainly. But the mechanism runs without them. All it needs is a sense that we are the good ones.

It is about ordinary people holding ordinary convictions about what is right.

Where the hope is hiding

I almost stopped reading there. Then I got to the fifth study, and that is where something turned.

The researchers had been tracking two things that usually travel together: the sense that your group is morally superior, and the sense that your group therefore stands higher. In the fifth study they pulled those apart and manipulated them separately.

Neither one alone produced dehumanization.

Not moral superiority on its own. Not a sense of higher standing on its own. Only the two together did it.

Hmmmmm.

Sit with that, because it changes the assignment entirely. Believing your values are right is not the problem. You are allowed to think some things are better than other things. You are allowed to have convictions, and the contemplative traditions have never asked anyone to give them up.

The problem comes when that belief converts into a sense of standing above. About being better than.

That middle step is where the damage enters. It is also the step nobody notices themselves taking.

And the researchers found something practical: when they emphasized equal standing between the groups, the whole effect weakened — even among people whose sense of moral superiority was running high. The work is not to hold our convictions more loosely. It is to stop letting them purchase us a higher place in the room.

Now the uncomfortable part

I have been sitting with this for several days, and here is where it finally caught me.

I have a wall of certificates that say I am self-aware. Master Certified Coach. Certified spiritual director. Narrative Enneagram teacher. I had never once thought to put that wall next to a study about moral superiority, and I am not enjoying the view now that I have.

Because inner work is a credential. And a credential confers standing.

Early in my coaching, before I understood the depth of what it actually means to be a coach, I watched someone else trying to do it. And I thought: that person should not be a coach.

I was looking at the outside of them from the outside of me. I had no idea what was happening in that room, or in them, or what they were carrying into it.

I see it differently now. Though I want to be honest about why. What changed me was going further into the ICF mentor coach work — more training, more assessment, another credential. So the thing that corrected my judgment was the same kind of thing that produced it in the first place. I am not sure what to do with that. I am suspicious of any version of this story where I come out clean.

There is a sentence I have heard in good rooms full of serious people, and I have said it myself more than once. They’re just not very self-aware.

Look at what that sentence does. It is a moral claim — awareness is a virtue in our world, maybe the central one. And it is a status claim in the same breath: I have the thing, they lack it, and that places us. Moral superiority plus perceived standing. Exactly the combination the fifth study isolated, delivered in a warm tone of voice.

We have a particularly refined version, too, because ours comes with humility built into the vocabulary. We can say bless them, they’re doing their best with the awareness they have and mean something quite unkind by it. The language of formation is unusually good at carrying contempt without leaving fingerprints.

I teach the Enneagram, which means I help people discover that there are nine distinct ways of being better than everyone else, and that theirs has a number. I say that as a joke. I am about forty percent sure it is one.

Why the tradition built the fences it did

This is where the old practices stop looking quaint to me.

The desert fathers and mothers had an almost absolute prohibition on judging another monk — not as etiquette, but as something closer to a safety rule. There are stories about a brother caught in open sin and the elders refusing to say a word against him. That always struck me as excessive. I am less sure now.

Consider the examen. It is turned inward, always, on yourself. There is no version of the practice where you examine the day’s conduct of other people. That is not an accident of design. It is a discipline built by people who had watched what happens when a sincere person starts keeping accounts on somebody else’s behavior, and who built the instrument so it could only point one direction.

The traditions were not naïve about human goodness. They were worried about exactly this — and worried enough to build fences that look, from the outside, like they go much too far.

Catching The Conversation Workbook

What I think we actually do

I do not think the answer is to stop having convictions. I hold mine. Some things are better than other things and I am not going to pretend otherwise at seventy-four.

What I think we do is watch for the conversion.

Notice the moment a conviction turns into a position. There is a specific feeling to it, and once you know the feeling you can catch it: a small lift, a settling, a sense of having been placed correctly in relation to someone. It is pleasant. That is what makes it so hard to see. It arrives disguised as clarity.

And then do the thing the fifth study says actually works, which is harder than it sounds. Put yourself back on level ground with the person you have just placed below you. Not by pretending you agree with them. By remembering that being right about a thing does not raise you one inch above anybody.

Ajené wrote that this saddens him, and it does. But I came away with something else as well, which I did not expect from a psychology paper.

The invitation is not to be less certain.

It is to stop standing on it.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Source

Zhang et al. (2026). When virtues are weaponized: Moral superiority aggravates outgroup dehumanization. Political Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1111/pops.70140

Spiritual Direction or Coaching Which Is Right?

SPIRITUAL DIRECTION SERIES  ·  POST 4 OF 6

The Difference Between Spiritual Direction and Coaching

Coaching helps you move toward something. Spiritual direction helps you pay attention to something.

People ask Jim and Lynette this question more than almost any other. It’s a fair one — they offer both, they’ve been trained deeply in both, and from the outside the two practices can look similar. Both involve one-on-one conversation. Both involve careful listening. Both are oriented toward growth and clarity.

So what’s actually different? The honest answer is: quite a lot. And Jim and Lynette have lived that difference from both sides — as practitioners and as people who have needed both at different points in their own lives.

What coaching is for

Coaching is fundamentally future-oriented. It begins with the question: where do you want to go, and what’s getting in the way?

Jim and Lynette spent years as Regional Network Directors for North America at Six Seconds — Josh Freedman’s global emotional intelligence nonprofit — and together co-developed the SEQ (Spiritual Emotional Intelligence) assessment now used across many countries. That work deepened their understanding of what coaching can do at its best: help people understand how their emotions inform their choices, interrupt patterns that are limiting them, and move toward what they most want with more skill and intentionality.

The Six Seconds model takes the inner life seriously. But it does so in service of forward movement. Coaching tends to work well when you have a goal you’re working toward, a decision you want to make more effectively, or a pattern you want to interrupt. It’s good for people who know roughly where they want to go and need help getting there.

What spiritual direction and spiritual formation are for

Spiritual direction and spiritual formation are fundamentally present-oriented — and in some ways, gently suspicious of the rush toward the future that coaching is designed to support.

When Lynette completed her Doctor of Ministry research at the Haden Institute and Graduate Theological Foundation, the work that eventually became the SEQ framework, she was exploring something the coaching world often moves past too quickly: the inner life not as a resource to optimize, but as a landscape to inhabit. Spiritual direction begins not with where do you want to go but with where are you, and what is already stirring in you?

A spiritual director isn’t working toward a goal with you. They’re paying attention alongside you — to what’s alive, to what’s heavy, to what keeps surfacing without resolution, to where the sacred might already be moving in ways you haven’t fully recognized yet.

The overlap — and why it matters

The two practices share more than they might seem to. Both take the inner life seriously. Both involve listening of a particular quality. Both resist the impulse to fix or advise.

Jim often says that the person who comes to him for coaching and the person who comes for spiritual direction are sometimes carrying the same question — they just haven’t recognized it yet. The executive trying to decide whether to take the promotion might actually be trying to understand what his life is for. The woman discerning a major transition might need both the practical clarity of coaching and the contemplative spaciousness of spiritual direction.

These aren’t competing practices. In Jim and Lynette’s experience, they’re part of the same one.

Which One Fits Where You Are Reflection Sheet

So how do you choose?

A few questions worth sitting with: Do you have a clear goal, or are you still trying to understand where you are? Are you looking for help with change, or help with understanding? Is there something specific you want to accomplish in the next year, or something you’ve been carrying that doesn’t seem to be going anywhere?

And — do you sense that what’s happening in your life right now has a deeper dimension you haven’t been able to name yet? If so, spiritual direction and the spaciousness of spiritual formation might be exactly what you’ve been looking for.

If you’re still not sure, the best next step is a free 15-minute conversation. Jim and Lynette can talk through where you are and what kind of companionship makes the most sense for this season.

Schedule with Jim: https://calendly.com/jim-792/spiritual-direction-consultation

Schedule with Lynette: https://calendly.com/lynettespiritofeq/15min

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Series

Post 4 of 6 in the Spiritual Direction series.