Posts

The Elder Is the One Who Can Be Asked

For thirteen years Lynette and I have been going to the same spiritual director.

Two chairs. A drink set down beside each of us. That particular few seconds before anyone speaks, when you both know what you came to say and neither of you has started. We go there to say out loud the things that do not get said anywhere else — and I have noticed that nothing gets said out loud in that room until somebody asks.

It happened in that room. I could not tell you now what had just been said — only that somebody had said something true, and in the quiet afterwards the holy crap light came on.

Not a thought. A piece of information arriving from lower down than thinking: this has changed. You are not the one carrying it any more. You are the one it gets brought to.

And the part I did not expect, and still cannot entirely explain, is that it was all right.

Hero to Elder

Connie Zweig, a psychotherapist who spent a career in the work before writing The Inner Work of Age, has a name for this passage. She calls it the shift from role to soul, and underneath it the move from Hero to Elder. I reached for the words doing to being before I ever read her, which I take as evidence that the thing is real and she simply got there first with language.

The Hero’s unit of value is capacity — what he can carry, fix, build, protect. I ran on that for forty years, and I have written elsewhere about the bill. The drive was not fair to the people around me, and some are still paying for it. That is the Hero’s characteristic damage. Not malice. Force, applied to people who had not asked for it.

The Elder’s unit of value is availability. Not what he can carry. What he can be asked.

Why the Hero cannot answer the only question that matters

I have been circling one question: what is mine to do?

It took me an embarrassing while to see why it would not resolve. The question is unanswerable to a Hero, because the Hero’s answer is always all of it. I am an Eight on the Enneagram, and here is what an Eight does — sees something shiny in the sand, rushes over, picks it up, turns it into something. Each time the thing was real and worth doing. Each time the picking-up was automatic.

Discernment requires something to decline with. You cannot sort what is yours from what is merely available while your sense of yourself depends on being able to take all of it. The move from hero to elder is not a pleasant development in late life. It is the thing that makes the question answerable at all.

What stands in the way is not time

Zweig came to this from shadow work — she co-wrote Meeting the Shadow long before she wrote about age. What blocks the passage is not the calendar. It is unconscious material: the denial and resistance that erupt at the thresholds of later life, mostly out of sight of the person they are happening to.

Every type has a version. For an Eight the disowned thing is need — not weakness in general, but the state of requiring something from someone who might not give it. I spent decades building a life in which that state was impossible, and I called the result strength.

Which is why the afternoon in that car park outside Florence went the way it did. Our car had been emptied, my passport with it, and I had been competent at a robbery all day. Then two colleagues arrived and asked what I needed first, and the thing I had spent forty years keeping out of the room walked in, and I could not hold it.

That is shadow doing what shadow does, and it is why a Hero cannot decide to become an Elder on a Tuesday. The material has to be met, and it does not surface on request. It surfaces when something takes your passport.

Where I already made the move, and where I have not

Here is the part I did not expect to find when I started writing this.

I have been doing elderhood for twenty years, professionally, without noticing. In the chair with a client or a directee, the one thing I will not do is tell them what to do. The choice is theirs, the consequences are theirs, and the only thing I have worth anything is a question they had not thought to ask themselves. People tell me, in almost the same phrase, that I never tell them what to do. I used to hear that as a compliment about technique. I think now it is a description of the office.

So the transition is not ahead of me at work. It is unfinished everywhere else.

An Eight fights for the people he cares about. That is my line and I have said it proudly. But I can let a client have their own consequences all day long, and whether I can let the people I love have theirs is a different question. I do not like my answer. The Hero is still fully operational in exactly the places where I care most.

A word, not a plan

An older man in the foreground watches a group of people seated around a table in conversation outdoors in warm afternoon light.

The monastics who went out into the Egyptian desert in the fourth century had no credentialing body — no application, no committee, no letters after anyone’s name. People walked out to where somebody was living, sat down, and said: abba, give me a word. Amma, if it was a woman. That was the whole transaction. Not a program, not a strategy — a word, something short and often strange, which the asker carried around for a year.

Notice who made the elder. The askers did. The office existed because people kept coming, and it would have ended the day they stopped. Which is the same shape as the thing I learned in Italy: an identity handed to you by other people, with no document in the transaction.

It also explains why advice is the Hero’s instrument and a word is the Elder’s. The Hero knows, and the knowing is proof of capacity. A word is offered and let go of, and whether anything comes of it is none of the giver’s business. You cannot give a word while you are still using your answers to prove something.

You cannot claim it. You can only become askable.

So what do you do, if you want the office and nobody is handing it out? Nothing that looks like applying. An elder who announces himself is seniority with a grievance. The only move available is to become the kind of person it makes sense to ask — reachable, honest about what you got wrong, done performing wisdom, and willing to be asked at an inconvenient hour by someone whose problem is not interesting.

Then the other half. The elder is not only the one who can be asked. The elder is the one who asks. Not let me know if you need anything, which hands the work back to the person already underwater. The four words two Italians used on me in a car park: what do you need first?

Anyone who asks that is doing the office, whatever their age.

What it costs, and the word I used

I will not pretend this is painless. It means being consulted less than you are capable of advising, with your influence running entirely on other people choosing to ask. After forty years of needing nobody’s permission to act, that is a real loss and I feel it.

What you get is larger and harder to name. The Hero is exhausting to be and exhausting to be near. People brace around a Hero. Nobody braces around an elder, which is exactly why they come.

Zweig was initiated as an Elder in a formal ceremony by a community that still performs them, and I am glad such things exist. But the ceremony did not make her one — it recognised something already underway. The rite ratifies; it cannot manufacture.

Which settles the question I have been circling since the passport. Everything else that proves me was issued by somebody and can be taken back in an afternoon — the title, the credentials, the body, the document in the drawer. This one is different, and not because it is more secure. It is different because it was never issued at all.

It is not a rank. It is a practice. And when I understood that, the word that came was not finally, and it was not at last. It was all right — the weight off the back arriving not as triumph but as permission.

Two chairs. A drink beside each of us. Somebody older than me has been doing this so quietly, for thirteen years, that it took me most of that time to notice it was a job.

A companion reflection sheet for this post: Who Comes to You (PDF).

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim Vaive and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ, where they work with leaders and seekers worldwide in coaching, training, and spiritual direction. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Dr. Lynette Vaive’s doctoral research is the scholarly foundation of the Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) framework. Together they write The Mystical Seeker on Substack and are co-authoring a book on SEQ. Reach them at jim@spiritofeq.com and lynette@spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Connie Zweig, The Inner Work of Age: Shifting from Role to Soul (Park Street Press, 2021), foreword by Harry R. Moody. Zweig is also co-author of Meeting the Shadow.

The form “give me a word” is from the sayings of the Desert Fathers and Mothers (the Apophthegmata Patrum), fourth-century Egypt.

Richard Rohr, “Our Life’s Call,” Daily Meditations, Center for Action and Contemplation, 13 November 2026.

© 2026 Spirit of EQ

The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With

The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With

I was dragging for years and calling it leadership.

We spent eight months preparing before Varment Guard opened its doors. Permits, trucks, equipment, the thousand small decisions nobody tells you about. And at some point in there I had four words put above the door where every person who worked for us would walk under them.

Failure is not an option.

I believed it. I still believe some of it. That sentence built a company that eventually employed hundreds of people, and I am not going to stand here at seventy-four and pretend it was a mistake. It worked.

But I have been thinking lately about what a sentence like that cannot admit, and about who pays for the part it leaves out.

What the shadow actually is

Richard Rohr has a line that has been following me around for a couple of years now: what we do not transform, we will transmit. He is talking about pain, mostly. But I have come to think it is just as true of the parts of ourselves we have never looked at directly — and that a leader transmits those at a volume nobody else in the building can match.

That is what the shadow is. Not the evil in us. The denied part. The material we have decided is not us, which goes on operating anyway, from underneath, with all the force of something that has never been questioned.

And here is the thing about shadow in leadership specifically. It does not usually show up as the obvious vice. It shows up disguised as your greatest strength, running past the point where the strength was useful.

Drive becomes a refusal to let anyone move at their own pace.

Decisiveness becomes an allergy to being slowed down by someone else’s thinking.

Protectiveness — and this one is mine — becomes the conviction that you are the only one who can carry it, which is not actually protection. It is a failure to trust the people you hired.

The ceiling I painted

Failure is not an option is a fine thing to say when you are eight months from opening and everything is uncertain. It is a different thing entirely when it becomes the air a hundred people breathe. Because what the people underneath that sentence hear is not courage. What they hear is: there is no room here to be struggling. No room to say the route is wrong, the schedule is impossible, I am in over my head, my marriage is coming apart and I cannot give you another sixty-hour week.

I thought I had painted a standard above that door. I had also painted a ceiling.

There are relationships from those years that are painful for me to think about now.

My drive was not fair to the people in the room. I harmed them. I am not going to dress that up or soften it into a lesson. I was not a monster — I was something more ordinary and more common, which is a man who mistook his own urgency for the right thing, and who ran people over while believing he was carrying them.

Most of them have gone on to successful lives in spite of me. That is the phrase that costs me. Not because of the hard training I thought I was giving them. In spite of me.

A few are still bitter. I understand why.

You cannot drag people

What I learned, far later than I should have, is the thing Jim Collins spent a book establishing: you cannot drag people along by sheer force of will. Collins went looking for what turned good companies into great ones and found that the leaders who did it were not the force-of-will personalities. They paired ferocious professional resolve with genuine personal humility — Level 5, he called it — and the magnetic, driving celebrity CEO turned up mostly in the comparison companies, the ones that did not make the leap. He put the sequence plainly too: first who, then what. The right people do not need to be dragged.

And if you are dragging, that is information about you. Not about them.

I was dragging for years and calling it leadership.

Why I keep teaching the Enneagram

This is where the Enneagram earns its keep for me, and why I keep teaching it to people who come in thinking it is a personality quiz.

The Enneagram is not fundamentally a description of how you behave. It is a description of what you are defending against, and the strategy you built so young that it stopped feeling like a strategy. Each type has a passion — the old tradition called them deadly sins, which overstates it — and the passion is precisely the engine that runs in the dark. For the Eight it is intensity, excess, too-muchness: the conviction that more force is always the answer, because force is what kept me safe once.

Nobody wakes up and decides to lead from their passion. That is the point. It is operating before you are awake.

And the instincts underneath — whether you are organized around self-preservation, around the social field, around the intensity of one-to-one connection — determine where that passion shows up first and most destructively. A self-preservation Eight hoards control over resources. A social Eight makes everything a question of loyalty to the group. These are not abstractions. They are Tuesday afternoon, in a meeting, in the thing you said that landed harder than you intended.

What the Enneagram gives a leader is not insight. Insight is cheap and most of us have plenty. It gives you a place to look before the damage, and a vocabulary for the thing you are about to do again.

Management with a title on it

Which brings me to what I actually want to say.

There is a kind of leadership that is competent, organized, well-reviewed, and entirely unexamined. The budgets balance. The people stay, mostly. The metrics are fine. And underneath it the leader is transmitting something they have never looked at — a fear, a hunger, an old wound in a good suit — and everyone in the organization is arranging themselves around it without ever being able to name what they are arranging themselves around.

That is not leadership. That is management with a title on it.

The difference is not charisma or vision or any of the words we put on the job posting. The difference is whether a person has done the work of meeting the part of themselves they would rather not meet, and keeps doing it, because it does not stay done.

Rohr’s point about transmission is the whole case for shadow work in a practical, unsentimental, bottom-line sense. You are going to transmit something. That is not optional. The only question on the table is whether you have looked at what you are sending.

The Strength That Went To Far Reflection Sheet

The door

I think about that door a lot now.

If I were painting it today, I would not take the words down. They were true about the work. We were building something that genuinely could not afford to fail, and saying so out loud was honest.

But I would want the people walking under it to know the rest of the sentence — the part I was not able to say then, because I had not met it yet. That failure was not an option for the company, and that this was never the same thing as there being no room to be human underneath it. That I was more afraid than I let anyone see. That the force I was leading with came from somewhere, and I had not yet asked where.

I would want to have known, standing there with the paint still wet, that what would cost us most was never going to be a bad quarter.

It was going to be the part of me I had decided was not worth examining, operating at full strength, for twenty years, over the heads of everyone walking through that door.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Richard Rohr on the shadow and on transformation — a recurring theme across his work, developed at length in Immortal Diamond (2013) and Falling Upward (2011).

Jim Collins, Good to Great (2001) — Level 5 Leadership and “first who, then what.”