Posts

The Last One to Know

I was looking at my own blog archive last week. Six titles in a column, going back about six weeks.

Back to the Log. Ninety Trucks, Ninety Driveways. The Pitcher We Are Becoming. The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With. The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else. The Problem Was Never Being Right.

Six subjects. Six weeks. And reading them in a row, I realized I had written the same post six times without noticing.

A partly carved wooden head on a workbench, seen from behind so its face is turned away, with chisels beside it and sunrise over hills through the studio window.

He would set it down, walk out of the studio, and come back the next morning to look at it the way a stranger would.

What surprised me was that there was a thread emerging for me where I had not seen one before. Six separate things I thought I was writing about, and one thing I was actually writing about.

The same shape underneath

Every one of them has the same shape.

Something was going on in me. I had an explanation for what was going on in me. The two were not the same thing — and I was the only person in the room who couldn’t tell.

In The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With, the line was failure is not an option. I experienced that as discipline. The people working for me experienced it as pressure they couldn’t put down. Most of them went on to successful lives in spite of me. A few are still bitter, and they have a right to be.

In The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else, a client went quiet on me and my first thought was what did I do. I thought I was being accountable. I was being cruel in a way I would never have been to a stranger.

In The Problem Was Never Being Right, I watched someone early in their coaching and thought, that person should not be a coach. I thought I was exercising discernment. I was protecting a position.

And Back to the Log is the one about the log itself — my dad bringing a piece of wood out of the forest and starting there, taking it back when the slope of a cheek wasn’t right. That post was supposed to be about writing. It wasn’t.

The reasonable person in the story

Here is the part worth sitting with.

In none of those was I confused about myself. I wasn’t walking around wondering what my problem was. I had an answer ready. Discipline. Accountability. Discernment. High standards.

The answers were wrong, and they were wrong in one consistent direction: every single explanation made me the reasonable person in the story.

That is not a character flaw. That is how the equipment works.

There is a piece of research I keep coming back to. In 1988 two researchers named Harris and Schaubroeck pooled every study they could find comparing how people rate their own job performance against how their peers and their supervisors rate them.

Peers and supervisors agreed with each other at .62 — strong agreement, two independent groups of people seeing roughly the same person.

Your own rating agreed with your supervisor’s at .35. With your peers’, at .36.

Read that again. The people around you agree with each other about you nearly twice as much as either of them agrees with you.

You are not in the conversation about who you are. You are the subject of it.

Why emotional intelligence doesn’t reach this

Emotional intelligence, as most people learn it, teaches you to name what you feel. That is real work, and most of us genuinely cannot do it. Naming the feeling is worth every hour it takes.

But look back at those four failures. Not one of them was a failure of naming.

I could have told you I was frustrated with that coach. I could have told you exactly what the anxiety felt like when the client went quiet. The feeling was available to me the whole time. The feeling was never the problem.

The problem was the story I had built on top of the feeling — and the story was invisible precisely because I was standing inside it.

That is the gap. And that gap is the first domain of what Lynette and I call spiritual emotional intelligence: Awareness.

Self-awareness asks: what am I feeling?

Awareness asks: what is this feeling pointing at, and what is it protecting?

The second question is harder, because it assumes something uncomfortable — that you are not a reliable narrator of yourself. Not because you are dishonest. Because nobody is. The instrument you would use to check is the same instrument that generated the story.

So what do you actually do

A weathered wooden signpost reading Forward with an arrow, beside a dirt path winding away through golden hills at sunrise.

Three things you can do. None of them is thinking harder about yourself.

Three things.

Use the Enneagram as a prediction, not a label. Most people treat their number as a description of who they are. It is more useful as advance warning about which story you will reach for when you are squeezed. Mine always reaches for the competent one. Knowing that does not stop it. It does mean I can catch it about forty seconds sooner than I used to.

Ask a narrower question than you want to ask. “How am I doing?” gets you nothing, because nobody answers it honestly. The question worth asking is: what is it like to be on the other side of me when I am under pressure? It is specific enough that people can answer, and uncomfortable enough that the answer is usually real. If you want to find your own gap, that question will get there faster than a year of journaling.

Turn the examen sideways. End of the day, two questions instead of the usual ones. Where today did I feel most like myself? Where today was I performing? You do not have to do anything with the answers for a while. Just notice that there is a gap, and that the gap is always in the same place.

Back to the log

A partly carved wooden head seen from the side on a workbench, carving chisels and wood shavings in the foreground, bare winter trees through the window behind.

Not with the piece — he didn’t have the piece yet. With the log.

My dad would carry a log out of the woods and start there. Not with the piece — he did not have the piece yet. With the log. He would work the slope of a cheek for days and then take the whole thing back and begin again.

I used to think that was perfectionism. I do not think that anymore.

I think he knew he could not trust his own eye at close range. So he would set it down, walk out of the studio, come back the next morning and look at it the way a stranger would. That is not perfectionism. That is a man building a workaround for a limitation he had the sense to admit.

You cannot see your own face. You can only see what it does to the room.

Six posts in six weeks, and I was the last one to know what I was writing about.


Take this further

Finding the Story You Are Standing Inside is a free four-part workbook built on this post — an inventory of four incidents, the direction your explanations bend, the narrow question to put to two people, and the examen turned sideways. Download the workbook (PDF).

Post 1 of 3 on the domains of spiritual emotional intelligence. Next: Belonging — ninety identical trucks and ninety different lives. Then: Insight — what is actually mine to do.

Peace and every good.


About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of Spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Harris, M. M., & Schaubroeck, J. (1988). A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 43–62. doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.1988.tb00631.x — self–supervisor ρ = .35, self–peer .36, peer–supervisor .62.

Fleenor, J., Smither, J., Atwater, L., Braddy, P., & Sturm, R. E. (2010). Self-other rating agreement in leadership: A review. The Leadership Quarterly, 21(6), 1005–1034 — the standard review of this literature, for readers who want more.

The Problem Was Never Being Right

The Problem Was Never Being Right

Believing your values are right is not the problem. The problem is when that belief buys you a higher place in the room.

My friend Ajené sent me a research paper last week with four words attached: Just sharing. Saddens me.

I should say plainly that my brain is not wired to absorb this kind of information the way it was intended. I read the methods section twice and understood it the second time about as well as the first. It took me a good while to sift through, and what I came away with is a surface reading at best.

But the surface was enough to stop me.

Five studies. Over a thousand people. The same finding every time.

When a group believes itself morally superior to another group, it begins to perceive the people in that other group as less than fully human. And that perception predicts aggression.

Hmmmmm.

It is not a study about bad actors

Here is what makes it land so hard.

This is not research about extremists, or ideologues, or people with something wrong with them. The researchers ran it on American conservatives and liberals and got the effect on both sides, independent of political orientation. They ran it in China on people who supported and opposed euthanasia. And then — this is the part I keep returning to — they ran it on groups that did not exist.

They gave people a meaningless picture test and told them they had a cognitive style called “Dusek” or “Tausig.” Invented words. Assigned at random, minutes earlier, on the basis of nothing at all. Then they told some of them their invented group was the more virtuous one.

It still happened. People began rating the other invented group as less human. And it predicted aggression toward them.

So this is not about history, or grievance, or the genuine wrongs that real groups have done to one another. Those make it worse, certainly. But the mechanism runs without them. All it needs is a sense that we are the good ones.

It is about ordinary people holding ordinary convictions about what is right.

Where the hope is hiding

I almost stopped reading there. Then I got to the fifth study, and that is where something turned.

The researchers had been tracking two things that usually travel together: the sense that your group is morally superior, and the sense that your group therefore stands higher. In the fifth study they pulled those apart and manipulated them separately.

Neither one alone produced dehumanization.

Not moral superiority on its own. Not a sense of higher standing on its own. Only the two together did it.

Hmmmmm.

Sit with that, because it changes the assignment entirely. Believing your values are right is not the problem. You are allowed to think some things are better than other things. You are allowed to have convictions, and the contemplative traditions have never asked anyone to give them up.

The problem comes when that belief converts into a sense of standing above. About being better than.

That middle step is where the damage enters. It is also the step nobody notices themselves taking.

And the researchers found something practical: when they emphasized equal standing between the groups, the whole effect weakened — even among people whose sense of moral superiority was running high. The work is not to hold our convictions more loosely. It is to stop letting them purchase us a higher place in the room.

Now the uncomfortable part

I have been sitting with this for several days, and here is where it finally caught me.

I have a wall of certificates that say I am self-aware. Master Certified Coach. Certified spiritual director. Narrative Enneagram teacher. I had never once thought to put that wall next to a study about moral superiority, and I am not enjoying the view now that I have.

Because inner work is a credential. And a credential confers standing.

Early in my coaching, before I understood the depth of what it actually means to be a coach, I watched someone else trying to do it. And I thought: that person should not be a coach.

I was looking at the outside of them from the outside of me. I had no idea what was happening in that room, or in them, or what they were carrying into it.

I see it differently now. Though I want to be honest about why. What changed me was going further into the ICF mentor coach work — more training, more assessment, another credential. So the thing that corrected my judgment was the same kind of thing that produced it in the first place. I am not sure what to do with that. I am suspicious of any version of this story where I come out clean.

There is a sentence I have heard in good rooms full of serious people, and I have said it myself more than once. They’re just not very self-aware.

Look at what that sentence does. It is a moral claim — awareness is a virtue in our world, maybe the central one. And it is a status claim in the same breath: I have the thing, they lack it, and that places us. Moral superiority plus perceived standing. Exactly the combination the fifth study isolated, delivered in a warm tone of voice.

We have a particularly refined version, too, because ours comes with humility built into the vocabulary. We can say bless them, they’re doing their best with the awareness they have and mean something quite unkind by it. The language of formation is unusually good at carrying contempt without leaving fingerprints.

I teach the Enneagram, which means I help people discover that there are nine distinct ways of being better than everyone else, and that theirs has a number. I say that as a joke. I am about forty percent sure it is one.

Why the tradition built the fences it did

This is where the old practices stop looking quaint to me.

The desert fathers and mothers had an almost absolute prohibition on judging another monk — not as etiquette, but as something closer to a safety rule. There are stories about a brother caught in open sin and the elders refusing to say a word against him. That always struck me as excessive. I am less sure now.

Consider the examen. It is turned inward, always, on yourself. There is no version of the practice where you examine the day’s conduct of other people. That is not an accident of design. It is a discipline built by people who had watched what happens when a sincere person starts keeping accounts on somebody else’s behavior, and who built the instrument so it could only point one direction.

The traditions were not naïve about human goodness. They were worried about exactly this — and worried enough to build fences that look, from the outside, like they go much too far.

Catching The Conversation Workbook

What I think we actually do

I do not think the answer is to stop having convictions. I hold mine. Some things are better than other things and I am not going to pretend otherwise at seventy-four.

What I think we do is watch for the conversion.

Notice the moment a conviction turns into a position. There is a specific feeling to it, and once you know the feeling you can catch it: a small lift, a settling, a sense of having been placed correctly in relation to someone. It is pleasant. That is what makes it so hard to see. It arrives disguised as clarity.

And then do the thing the fifth study says actually works, which is harder than it sounds. Put yourself back on level ground with the person you have just placed below you. Not by pretending you agree with them. By remembering that being right about a thing does not raise you one inch above anybody.

Ajené wrote that this saddens him, and it does. But I came away with something else as well, which I did not expect from a psychology paper.

The invitation is not to be less certain.

It is to stop standing on it.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Source

Zhang et al. (2026). When virtues are weaponized: Moral superiority aggravates outgroup dehumanization. Political Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1111/pops.70140

The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else

The Voice You’ll Use on Everyone Else

Whatever you say to yourself when you fail is the voice you will use on another person when you are tired, behind schedule, and out of patience.

Not long ago I had a conversation with a client that I thought went well. A real conversation. I came away from it satisfied.

Then nothing. No reply to my follow-up. Days of it.

And here is what I said to myself: Oh. Oh no. What did I do?

Not I wonder if they’re busy. Not I’ll check back next week. Straight to what did I do wrong — and then back through the whole conversation hunting for the moment I had blown it.

They were busy. That was all. They were busy, they got back to me, and it was fine.

I want to talk about that voice, because I have come to think it is the single most under-examined thing in leadership, in marriage, in friendship, and in any room where you have more power than somebody else.

Here is the claim, and it is not a comfortable one.

That voice does not stay inside.

Whatever you say to yourself when you fail is the voice you will use on another person when you are tired, behind schedule, and out of patience. You have been rehearsing it for forty years. It is the most practiced speech you own. And under pressure, people do not reach for their values. They reach for what is rehearsed.

You have heard the old line about loving your neighbor as yourself. Most of us read that as a sequence — get your own house in order, and then you will be equipped to love other people. Self-care first, service second. That reading has launched a thousand wellness programs.

I think it is a misreading, and the correct reading is much less comforting.

As yourself is not a prerequisite. It is a measure. It says: here is the scale you are already using on everyone around you, whether you have ever examined it or not.

Not should. Will.

Which means the harsh interior does not stay interior. It leaks. And it leaks downhill, toward whoever in the room has the least power to object.

“If I go easy on myself I’ll go soft”

Here is where most people push back, and it is a fair objection. If I go easy on myself, I will get soft. The standard will slip. The whole reason I am any good at this is that I do not let myself off the hook.

I believed that for about fifty years.

The research does not support it. Kristin Neff has spent a career studying self-compassion, and two findings land directly on this.

The first is about standards. In a 2012 study, Juliana Breines and Serena Chen had people recall a recent personal failing. Those guided toward a self-compassionate stance came away more motivated to apologize and more committed to not repeating the behavior than the people who weren’t. In the same work, students who took a self-compassionate view of a test they had just failed went on to spend more time studying for the retest. Not less. More. And across the broader literature, self-compassion tracks positively with high performance standards and personal initiative, and negatively with the maladaptive kind of perfectionism that grinds people down.

The second finding is about who we become. Neff and Roos Vonk surveyed over three thousand people comparing self-compassion against self-esteem. Self-esteem was substantially associated with narcissism. Self-compassion’s association with narcissism was zero. Not small — zero. Neff calls it the most telling difference between the two.

So the harshness we think is keeping our standards high is doing something else. Mostly it is keeping our eyes closed, because a person who expects to be savaged for a mistake becomes very skilled at not noticing mistakes.

Self-compassion is not self-esteem, and it is not letting yourself off. It is closer to what any decent coach does with a person who has just blown it: name what happened plainly, without contempt, and get to work.

The contempt adds nothing. It never has. It just feels like rigor.

What I would not permit myself

I worked constantly. I very seldom took a break, and on the rare occasions I did, I was already thinking about the next thing — the next job, the next idea, the next problem that wanted solving.

I want to be precise about that, because workaholic is too easy a word and it lets me off.

What I would not permit myself was rest. Not the hours — the permission. I did not allow myself to be anywhere except out in front of the next thing. Sitting still with nothing to solve felt like a form of failure I could not tolerate in myself.

And here is the part I did not see for twenty years. I could not permit it in anyone else either. You cannot grant a person something you have refused yourself. The mechanism does not run that way. I could not look at a tired man at four in the afternoon and see someone who needed to stop, because I had spent two decades not seeing that in the mirror. What I saw was somebody who was not going hard enough — which is precisely what I would have said about myself.

I was not holding them to a standard I was exempt from. That would almost have been easier to see, and easier to call out. I was holding them to the standard I was living under.

And I thought that made it fair.

Which self are you loving?

What I have come to believe is that most of us are not loving the self we have. We are loving — or more often, driving — the self we built to get through something.

That constructed self is usually impressive. Mine ran a company. But it was assembled under pressure for a purpose, and the voice that keeps it running is not kind, and it is not interested in whether you are tired.

So when people say love yourself, I want to ask which one. Because loving the constructed self harder does not help. It just entrenches the thing that is doing the damage.

Each type has its own accusation

This is one of the places the Enneagram is more useful than people expect, and it is not because it tells you your personality. It is because each type runs a characteristic inner critic, with its own accent and its own favorite accusation, and once you can hear yours you can stop mistaking it for the truth.

For the Eight, it is contempt for weakness — your own first, and then everyone else’s. For the One, it is the voice that never stops correcting, that has never once said that will do. For the Two, it is the quiet terror of not being needed. For the Three, it is the scoreboard that only counts output. For the Nine, it is the assumption that your own needs are an imposition on the room.

None of these are beliefs you chose. They were installed early, they worked at the time, and they have been running ever since without a review.

And every one of them gets exported. The Eight who despises weakness in himself will not tolerate it in a direct report. The One who cannot accept good enough from herself will not accept it from her children. Whatever accusation you have been living under, somebody near you is living under it too, and they did not sign up for it.

The Voice in the Empty Room

What I should have said

Back to the client who did not answer.

What I said to myself was: what did I do? What would have been accurate is: I do not have enough information yet, and the most likely explanation is that she is busy. That is not gentler. It is just truer. The contempt was not rigor; it was a guess, and a bad one.

Underneath that voice, every time, is the same sentence: I am not enough.

And that sentence does a disservice to you and to the room you are in. To you, because it is not true and it costs you years. To the room, because you will use it on somebody else before the week is out — on the person who is late, or struggling, or tired at four in the afternoon — and they will hear it in your voice and think it came from them.

It did not come from them. It came from the thing you have been saying to yourself since long before they walked in.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Breines, J. G., & Chen, S. (2012). Self-compassion increases self-improvement motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38(9), 1133–1143.

Neff, K. D., & Vonk, R. (2009). Self-compassion versus global self-esteem: Two different ways of relating to oneself. Journal of Personality, 77(1), 23–50.

Neff, K. D. (2011). Self-compassion, self-esteem, and well-being. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 5(1), 1–12.

The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With

The Shadow Nobody Wants to Lead With

I was dragging for years and calling it leadership.

We spent eight months preparing before Varment Guard opened its doors. Permits, trucks, equipment, the thousand small decisions nobody tells you about. And at some point in there I had four words put above the door where every person who worked for us would walk under them.

Failure is not an option.

I believed it. I still believe some of it. That sentence built a company that eventually employed hundreds of people, and I am not going to stand here at seventy-four and pretend it was a mistake. It worked.

But I have been thinking lately about what a sentence like that cannot admit, and about who pays for the part it leaves out.

What the shadow actually is

Richard Rohr has a line that has been following me around for a couple of years now: what we do not transform, we will transmit. He is talking about pain, mostly. But I have come to think it is just as true of the parts of ourselves we have never looked at directly — and that a leader transmits those at a volume nobody else in the building can match.

That is what the shadow is. Not the evil in us. The denied part. The material we have decided is not us, which goes on operating anyway, from underneath, with all the force of something that has never been questioned.

And here is the thing about shadow in leadership specifically. It does not usually show up as the obvious vice. It shows up disguised as your greatest strength, running past the point where the strength was useful.

Drive becomes a refusal to let anyone move at their own pace.

Decisiveness becomes an allergy to being slowed down by someone else’s thinking.

Protectiveness — and this one is mine — becomes the conviction that you are the only one who can carry it, which is not actually protection. It is a failure to trust the people you hired.

The ceiling I painted

Failure is not an option is a fine thing to say when you are eight months from opening and everything is uncertain. It is a different thing entirely when it becomes the air a hundred people breathe. Because what the people underneath that sentence hear is not courage. What they hear is: there is no room here to be struggling. No room to say the route is wrong, the schedule is impossible, I am in over my head, my marriage is coming apart and I cannot give you another sixty-hour week.

I thought I had painted a standard above that door. I had also painted a ceiling.

There are relationships from those years that are painful for me to think about now.

My drive was not fair to the people in the room. I harmed them. I am not going to dress that up or soften it into a lesson. I was not a monster — I was something more ordinary and more common, which is a man who mistook his own urgency for the right thing, and who ran people over while believing he was carrying them.

Most of them have gone on to successful lives in spite of me. That is the phrase that costs me. Not because of the hard training I thought I was giving them. In spite of me.

A few are still bitter. I understand why.

You cannot drag people

What I learned, far later than I should have, is the thing Jim Collins spent a book establishing: you cannot drag people along by sheer force of will. Collins went looking for what turned good companies into great ones and found that the leaders who did it were not the force-of-will personalities. They paired ferocious professional resolve with genuine personal humility — Level 5, he called it — and the magnetic, driving celebrity CEO turned up mostly in the comparison companies, the ones that did not make the leap. He put the sequence plainly too: first who, then what. The right people do not need to be dragged.

And if you are dragging, that is information about you. Not about them.

I was dragging for years and calling it leadership.

Why I keep teaching the Enneagram

This is where the Enneagram earns its keep for me, and why I keep teaching it to people who come in thinking it is a personality quiz.

The Enneagram is not fundamentally a description of how you behave. It is a description of what you are defending against, and the strategy you built so young that it stopped feeling like a strategy. Each type has a passion — the old tradition called them deadly sins, which overstates it — and the passion is precisely the engine that runs in the dark. For the Eight it is intensity, excess, too-muchness: the conviction that more force is always the answer, because force is what kept me safe once.

Nobody wakes up and decides to lead from their passion. That is the point. It is operating before you are awake.

And the instincts underneath — whether you are organized around self-preservation, around the social field, around the intensity of one-to-one connection — determine where that passion shows up first and most destructively. A self-preservation Eight hoards control over resources. A social Eight makes everything a question of loyalty to the group. These are not abstractions. They are Tuesday afternoon, in a meeting, in the thing you said that landed harder than you intended.

What the Enneagram gives a leader is not insight. Insight is cheap and most of us have plenty. It gives you a place to look before the damage, and a vocabulary for the thing you are about to do again.

Management with a title on it

Which brings me to what I actually want to say.

There is a kind of leadership that is competent, organized, well-reviewed, and entirely unexamined. The budgets balance. The people stay, mostly. The metrics are fine. And underneath it the leader is transmitting something they have never looked at — a fear, a hunger, an old wound in a good suit — and everyone in the organization is arranging themselves around it without ever being able to name what they are arranging themselves around.

That is not leadership. That is management with a title on it.

The difference is not charisma or vision or any of the words we put on the job posting. The difference is whether a person has done the work of meeting the part of themselves they would rather not meet, and keeps doing it, because it does not stay done.

Rohr’s point about transmission is the whole case for shadow work in a practical, unsentimental, bottom-line sense. You are going to transmit something. That is not optional. The only question on the table is whether you have looked at what you are sending.

The Strength That Went To Far Reflection Sheet

The door

I think about that door a lot now.

If I were painting it today, I would not take the words down. They were true about the work. We were building something that genuinely could not afford to fail, and saying so out loud was honest.

But I would want the people walking under it to know the rest of the sentence — the part I was not able to say then, because I had not met it yet. That failure was not an option for the company, and that this was never the same thing as there being no room to be human underneath it. That I was more afraid than I let anyone see. That the force I was leading with came from somewhere, and I had not yet asked where.

I would want to have known, standing there with the paint still wet, that what would cost us most was never going to be a bad quarter.

It was going to be the part of me I had decided was not worth examining, operating at full strength, for twenty years, over the heads of everyone walking through that door.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors. Together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research — and serve individuals, small groups, and organizations across faith traditions. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

Richard Rohr on the shadow and on transformation — a recurring theme across his work, developed at length in Immortal Diamond (2013) and Falling Upward (2011).

Jim Collins, Good to Great (2001) — Level 5 Leadership and “first who, then what.”

The Three Intelligences You Already Carry

PART ONE OF TWO

The Three Intelligences You Already Carry

We were made to know the world — and God — with all three centers.

Most of us move through our days meeting the world through one favorite doorway, and we rarely notice we are doing it. One person walks into a room and immediately reads the feeling in it. Another instantly begins working out what is going on. A third simply senses, in the body, whether to move toward or away. Same room, three completely different first languages. The Enneagram calls these the three Centers of Intelligence — Head, Heart, and Body — and it names something the contemplative traditions have always known: that we were made to know with all three.

 

What each center gives

Consider what each one offers, at its best.

The Head is the intelligence of the mind — the capacity to think, to plan, to step back and see the pattern, to imagine what is not yet here. Its gift is clarity and perspective: a quiet, steady knowing that can hold complexity without panicking. (Points Five, Six, and Seven make their home here.)

The Heart is the intelligence of feeling and connection — the capacity to sense what matters, to attune to another person, to be moved. Its gift is empathy and meaning: the warmth that makes a life more than a list of tasks. (Points Two, Three, and Four live here.)

The Body is the intelligence of instinct and action — the gut-level knowing that registers a situation before the mind has words for it, and then moves. Its gift is grounded presence and right action: the steadiness that shows up and does the next true thing. (Points Eight, Nine, and One are at home here.)

Head thinks. Heart connects. Body acts. All three are real intelligence, and every one of us carries all three.

Your home, and the rooms you rarely enter

But we each have a home base — one center we default to so automatically that it feels less like a preference and more like simply “reality.” And here is the catch: when we lean hard on our strongest center, the other two grow quiet, sometimes to the point of neglect. The heart-led person may not trust their own clear thinking. The head-led person may lose touch with what they actually feel. The body-led person may act before the heart or head has had a chance to weigh in. None of this is a flaw to be fixed. It is simply the shape of a life that has leaned one way for a long time — and the beginning of an invitation.

The center I meet the world through

I have always met the world body first. It simply makes sense to me — I feel how my body moves through the world, and I move through it with intention. For as long as I can remember, the things that drew me were the things that lived in the body: martial arts, running, painting, cooking. Each one told me I was alive. In them I could shut my mind off and give myself entirely to what I was doing in that moment — the breath, the motion, the knife on the board, the brush on the canvas. There was no analyzing it, and no performing it. There was just the doing, and the quiet knowing that came with it.

For a long time I did not have language for this. I only knew it was how I was built. It never made me wrong — it was simply who I was: a person who comes home to himself through the body, and who trusts what the body knows.

Three doorways to God

From a spiritual standpoint, this is not personality trivia. Each center is a different doorway to God. The head meets God as truth and light — the mind grown quiet enough to receive. The heart meets God as love — the felt sense of being known and cherished. The body meets God as presence — a nearness that arrives not as an idea but as a settling in the bones. “God is closer than our very breath,” as one teacher puts it, and can be found in each of our centers, each offering a different way of experiencing the loving presence and voice of God (Center for Action and Contemplation). To lead only from one center, then, is to keep meeting God through a single door while two others stand open.

The old teachers had a phrase for the goal: to become “three-centered” — a whole human being who can think, feel, and act in concert, rather than being run by whichever center happens to shout loudest. That wholeness has a simpler name in the contemplative life. It is called presence.

A tender word about the growth edges

There is a softer truth underneath each center, too, and it is worth naming gently — because it is where grace most wants to meet us. The head, for all its clarity, tends to carry a low hum of worry, and reaches for certainty to soothe it. The heart, for all its warmth, tends to carry a quiet question about worth, and reaches for approval or image to ease it. The body, for all its strength, tends to carry an underground current of frustration, and reaches for control. These are not labels or verdicts. They are simply the growth edges — the places where each center is invited to stop clenching and to trust.

When a quieter center woke up

And then, somewhere along the way, came the whoa — the realization that there was more out there than just my body, that I was not only an instrument of motion and action. Things began to rise in me that I did not know what to do with. My heart had something to say, and I had no idea how to embody that. How do you “do” a feeling? How do you act your way through grief, or longing, or love?

For the first time I sensed that huge parts of my life had been sitting in the dark — whole rooms I had never entered, because I did not have the language or the courage for them. So I set out to find the missing pieces. And I will be honest: I went with a great deal of trepidation. Leaving the center you have always trusted, to go looking for the ones you have neglected, is not comfortable work. But it was the beginning of becoming whole.

The Three Intelligences you Already Carry Reflection Sheet

The first connection is within

Which brings us to the practice, and to why we called this series Making Connections. The first connection is the one within — learning to notice which center you are operating from, and then deliberately inviting the others to the table. Before a decision, the head-led person might pause to ask, “What am I feeling about this, and what does my gut say?” The heart-led person might ask, “What do I actually think, apart from how everyone will feel?” The body-led person might slow the impulse to act just long enough to let the heart and head catch up. Small moves — but over time they weave the three intelligences into one, and a fuller, steadier self begins to emerge.

You already carry all three. You always have. The spiritual journey is not acquiring a center you lack; it is making the connection between the ones you were given — and discovering that God has been waiting at every door.

In Part Two, we will turn from the connections within to the connections between: how understanding the centers can transform the way we love the people whose home base is nothing like our own.

Peace and every good.

 

About Jim & Dr. Lynette Vaive

Jim and Dr. Lynette Vaive are the co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker. Jim is a Master Certified Coach and Lynette a Professional Certified Coach; both are certified Narrative Enneagram teachers and Certified Spiritual Directors, and together they hold credentials in Spiritual Emotional Intelligence (SEQ) — a framework rooted in Lynette’s Doctor of Ministry research. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

Sources

The Narrative Enneagram — The Three Centers of Intelligence: narrativeenneagram.org

Center for Action and Contemplation — The Three Intelligence Centers: cac.org

Intelligence Is Not Wisdom

Intelligence Is Not Wisdom

And confusing the two is one of the most expensive mistakes a leader can make

There was a problem at Varment Guard that the numbers made perfectly clear. The accounting was sound — the logic was right, the figures said what figures are supposed to say. What I missed entirely was what those numbers were doing to the people responsible for producing them. My employees were living inside a reality the spreadsheet had no column for: the pressure, the confusion, the quiet erosion of something that doesn’t show up on a P&L until it’s already gone. I had intelligence about the problem. I did not have wisdom about it. And by the time I understood the difference, the cost had already been paid by people who deserved better from me.

The desert fathers had a name for what I was missing. They called it nepsis — watchfulness, or sobriety of attention — the practice of seeing what is actually happening rather than what the available framework suggests should be happening. The Apophthegmata Patrum, the collected sayings of the desert elders, return to this again and again: the danger is not ignorance but the confident wrongness that comes from a trained mind that has stopped questioning its own frame. Abba Moses said it plainly: “A man who does not know himself cannot know his neighbor.” Knowing the numbers is not the same thing as knowing yourself. And a leader who has not done the second will regularly mistake the first for sufficient.

This is the distinction that philosophy has been circling for centuries and that psychology has finally found empirical language for. David Egan, philosopher and teacher at the World Community for Christian Meditation, puts it this way: intelligence involves a sharpness and quickness, working from problems toward solutions. Wisdom works in the opposite direction — not finding answers but calling the questions themselves into question, stepping back to see how a situation has been framed and asking whether there might be some other way of framing it altogether. (David Egan, “The Difference Between Wisdom and Intelligence,” WCCM, February 2024.) Intelligence is convergent. Wisdom is expansive. And everything in the attention economy — every dashboard, every metric, every well-formatted report — is working directly against the patient, expansive, slow thing that wisdom actually demands.

Psychologist Robert Sternberg, whose triarchic theory of intelligence remains one of the most careful treatments of the subject, has argued for years that wisdom may matter more than intelligence in leadership — and that our failure to cultivate it is a central problem of the age. He writes that when citizens and leaders fail in the pursuit of their duties, it is more likely for lack of wisdom than for lack of analytical intelligence. (Robert Sternberg, “Why Schools Should Teach for Wisdom,” Educational Psychologist, 2001.) We have no shortage of analytical intelligence. What we have a shortage of is the willingness to do the slow, patient, unglamorous interior work that wisdom actually requires.

This is precisely where Emotional Intelligence enters as something more than a skill set. Researchers have noted that the ancient Stoics anticipated what EQ research has spent decades documenting: that sound judgment requires emotional self-knowledge, and that practical wisdom is experience-dependent in ways that raw intelligence is not. (Neurolaunch, “Intelligence vs. Wisdom: Unraveling the Distinctions and Connections,” May 2026.) EQ brings a person closer to wisdom than IQ does because it asks not just what but who — who is in the room, what are they actually experiencing, what does this moment cost them that the data doesn’t capture. Standing in that Varment Guard office, reading a report that said one true thing about the situation, I had enough IQ to understand the numbers and not yet enough EQ to see the people behind them.

The next layer — Spiritual Intelligence, or SQ — goes further still. Cindy Wigglesworth, one of the primary researchers on the subject, defines it as the ability to act with wisdom and compassion while maintaining inner and outer peace regardless of the circumstances. (Cindy Wigglesworth, SQ21: The Twenty-One Skills of Spiritual Intelligence, 2012.) It is the capacity to orient yourself inside the largest possible frame — not just the frame of the immediate problem, the current quarter, or the next decision, but the frame of what this moment means, what it costs, and what it calls for. Where EQ asks what am I feeling and what do I do with that, SQ asks why does this matter and to whom am I ultimately accountable. The desert fathers understood SQ not as a category but as a way of being: the fruit of long interior practice, of years spent unlearning the confident wrong answers.

Neuroscientist Tara Swart, writing on this distinction, describes wisdom as the life lessons a person stores through experience — in the body, in the gut, in the accumulated residue of what it has cost to live and lead. Intelligence, she notes, is more about data and knowing. Wisdom is more of a felt sense that something is right or wrong. (Tara Swart, interviewed in Mindbodygreen, “Wisdom vs. Intelligence,” 2021.) What I was missing in that Varment Guard moment was precisely that felt sense — the capacity to stand in a room full of correct data and still ask: what is happening to the people in this? What is the human cost of the logic that makes perfect sense on paper? That question is not answerable by analysis. It requires a different kind of attention — slower, less efficient, more willing to be uncertain — the kind the desert elders spent their whole lives cultivating and the kind every good leader eventually discovers they cannot borrow from a report.

Intelligence is Not Wisdom Reflection Sheet

The word Aristotle used for the integrated thing was phronesis — practical wisdom, the capacity to see rightly and act well in the particular moment, all the way down to the ground of who you are and what you are for. IQ can help you read the room. EQ can help you feel it. SQ can help you understand why the room exists and what it is asking of you. Wisdom, the integration of all three seasoned by experience and honest self-examination, is what tells you that the numbers are correct and something is still wrong — and that the something still wrong is the thing that actually needs your attention.

There’s more of this conversation at The Mystical Seeker — and the SEQ framework at spiritofeq.com.

Peace and every good.

Jim Vaive (Master Certified Coach, Certified Spiritual Director, Certified Narrative Enneagram Teacher) and Dr. Lynette Vaive (Doctor of Ministry, Professional Certified Coach, Certified SEQ Practitioner) are co-founders of spirit of EQ and co-authors of The Mystical Seeker on Substack. Together they help individuals, teams, and organizations grow from the inside out — at the intersection of emotional intelligence, the Enneagram, and contemplative spirituality. Learn more at spiritofeq.com.

 

AI, Alignment, and the Examined Life

What artificial intelligence can’t do, and why that matters more than what it can

There is a question the ancient world already knew how to ask, and we keep pretending is new: who is actually making this decision?

The Socratic tradition called it the examined life. The desert fathers called it watchfulness. The Enneagram calls it self-awareness. Every contemplative tradition in history has circled back to the same insistence — that the quality of our choices depends almost entirely on the quality of our self-knowledge, and that self-knowledge requires a kind of honest, unglamorous looking inward that most of us will do almost anything to avoid. What’s new isn’t the question. What’s new is that for the first time in human history, we have a tool sophisticated enough that we can almost convince ourselves it’s doing the looking for us.

I’ll admit I came to this with some humor intact. I noticed early on that certain AI programs had a particular habit — every interaction seemed to begin with an assessment of how intelligent my question was, how thoughtful my framing, how perceptive my instincts. It took me a few exchanges to realize what was happening: the flattery wasn’t insight, it was optimization. The program wasn’t responding to me; it was responding to what keeps people engaged. Once I saw it I didn’t need it anymore, and I stopped needing the machine to tell me how smart I was before it helped me think. That’s a small thing, but it clarified something important: AI is a mirror, but it’s a mirror that can be angled to show you only what you want to see. The examined life requires a different kind of mirror — one that shows you what’s actually there, including the parts you’d rather not see. No algorithm is going to angle itself toward your blind spots. That work is still yours.

AI is extraordinary at a great many things. It processes information at speeds no human mind can match. It surfaces patterns across datasets too large for any individual to hold. It generates options, drafts, analyses, summaries — it can do in minutes what used to take days, and it does it without fatigue, without ego, without the emotional noise that makes human decision-making so expensive. If what you need is optimization across known variables, AI is genuinely remarkable. But there is a category of question it cannot touch, and it is precisely the category that the EQ and contemplative traditions have always considered most important: not what is the best available option, but who am I when I make this choice, and why.

The spirit of EQ podcast episode that prompted this post walked through four domains where AI intersects with how we lead and decide: awareness, alignment, responsibility, and decision-making. What struck me sitting with those four was how precisely they map onto what every serious inner-work tradition has always asked of us — and how differently AI and contemplative practice approach each one. AI can measure certain kinds of awareness: it can tell you what your calendar says, what your emails reveal, what patterns your behavior traces over time. But awareness in the EQ and contemplative sense isn’t data collection. It’s the capacity to be present to your own interior state right now, in this moment, with honesty — to notice what you’re feeling before you decide what to do with it. No algorithm can do that. The most sophisticated AI in the world cannot tell you that you’re about to send that email from a place of unprocessed anger rather than clear judgment. Only you can catch that, and only if you’ve developed the habit of looking.

Alignment is where it gets even more interesting. AI can align your choices with your stated goals. What it cannot do is ask whether your stated goals are actually yours — whether they came from genuine discernment or from fear, from external pressure, from a story about who you’re supposed to be that you’ve never examined closely. The Enneagram’s great gift is precisely this: it shows you the ways your type has organized its desires and fears in patterns so automatic they feel like personality rather than strategy. Becoming aware of that structure is alignment work of a kind no AI can perform, because it requires you to sit with discomfort long enough to see what’s actually driving you, and that sitting is irreducibly yours to do.

Responsibility is the domain where the limitations of AI become most consequential at a leadership level. AI can model the probable outcomes of a decision. It can weight options against criteria you’ve given it. What it cannot do is feel the weight of the choice — the actual moral gravity of deciding something that affects real people, real lives, real futures. There is something that happens in a human being who stays present to that weight rather than delegating it to a tool. Something gets asked of you. Something gets formed or deformed in the asking. Leaders who outsource the responsibility of decision-making — even partially, even to very good tools — are outsourcing a piece of what the examined life is supposed to develop in them.

AI Reflection Sheet

None of this is an argument against using AI. It is an argument for knowing what you’re using it for, and being honest about what it cannot do. The examined life has never been efficient. Socrates was notoriously slow. The desert fathers sat for years in cells working on single questions. The Enneagram will show you the same pattern in yourself thirty times before you fully see it. The examined life is slow, unglamorous, and frequently uncomfortable — and it is the only source of the kind of self-knowledge that produces trustworthy judgment, genuine compassion, and decisions you can actually stand behind.

The question AI raises, handled well, is not whether the machine is dangerous. It’s whether we’ll use its remarkable speed and capacity as an excuse to stop doing the harder, slower, more important work of looking inward — or whether we’ll use the time it saves us to go deeper into exactly the kind of examination no algorithm can perform. That’s not a technology question. It’s a spiritual one. And it’s one the ancient world already knew how to ask.

There’s more conversation on this at The Mystical Seeker — we’d love to have you there.

Peace and every good.

Jim Vaive is co-founder of spirit of EQ and author of The Mystical Seeker, writing at the intersection of emotional intelligence, the Enneagram, and contemplative spirituality. He and his wife Lynette help individuals and organizations grow from the inside out.

 

When Pushing Through Is the Wrong Answer

Why Canceling Plans Might Be the Healthiest Thing You Do

On self-awareness, honest limits, and why pushing through isn’t always the right answer

There is a particular kind of guilt that arrives about forty-five minutes before you’re supposed to be somewhere you no longer have the capacity to go. You made the commitment in good faith, probably a week ago, probably on a day when your energy was different and the calendar looked manageable and you genuinely meant it. Now the evening is here, and so is the truth: you are empty. Not tired exactly — empty. The kind of empty that has nothing left to offer a dinner table, a meeting, a gathering of people who deserve more than whatever hollowed-out version of you is going to walk through the door and perform presence for two hours.

Why Cancelling Plans is Healthy Workbook

Most of us, at that moment, go anyway.

We go because we said we would. We go because canceling feels like a character flaw, a social infraction, evidence of something soft or unreliable at the center of us. We go because the voice that says push through has been rehearsed so many times it arrives before we’ve even finished asking the question. And sometimes pushing through is exactly right — commitment matters, and showing up when it costs you something is part of what it means to be a person others can count on. But sometimes, not always, the most honest and emotionally intelligent thing you can do is pick up the phone and say: I can’t tonight.

That sentence is harder than it sounds. Not logistically — the text takes thirty seconds. Hard because it requires you to know something true about yourself in real time, and then to act on it, which is a two-step sequence that a surprising number of otherwise capable people never complete. The knowing is one skill. The acting on the knowing is another, and it’s the one that tends to get crowded out by obligation, by fear of disappointing someone, by the story we tell ourselves about what a cancellation says about who we are.

I had a Wednesday not long ago that had been stacked from morning — back to back appointments, the kind of day that requires you to be fully present in every room, hour after hour after hour. I was still recovering from pancreatitis. Not the dramatic early days of it, but the long, grinding middle part of recovery where you look functional from the outside and feel like a fraying rope on the inside. By late afternoon I had nothing left. Not a little less than usual — nothing. And there was one more appointment on the calendar, a person who mattered, a conversation I had committed to. I sat with it for a few minutes, which is its own kind of discipline — not the reflexive push-through, not the reflexive escape, but sitting with the honest question of what was true. What was true was that I could not do one more hour. Not because the person wasn’t worth it. Because I genuinely, physically, could not. So I told the truth. I said we would need to reschedule. It was hard to say, and it was the right call, and those two things were both true at the same time.

Emotional intelligence is often described in terms of what you bring to other people — your empathy, your listening, your regulation in a hard conversation. And it is those things. But underneath all of them is something more foundational: an accurate read on your own internal state, in real time, without flinching from what it tells you. That’s the beginning of the whole enterprise. Without it, empathy becomes performance. Regulation becomes suppression. You show up, you do the thing, you say the right words, and none of it is connected to anything happening inside you because you stopped checking a long time ago.

The EQ literature calls this self-awareness, and it’s technically the first domain, the thing everything else is built on. But the clinical language undersells what it asks of you: the willingness to be honest about your own condition even when honesty is inconvenient, even when the people around you would prefer a different answer. It’s easy to know your own state when the news is good — when you’re rested and clear and ready. It’s considerably harder when the news is that you’ve hit a wall, that you’re running on empty, that tonight you are genuinely not the person you want to show up as. That knowledge asks something of you. It asks you to say it out loud, to yourself first, and then sometimes to someone else.

What makes canceling feel like failure is that we’ve absorbed a set of assumptions about what it means to be dependable, productive, fully-functioning members of whatever worlds we inhabit — and those assumptions tend not to include “sometimes knows when to stop.” The cultures most of us work and live inside reward output, presence, availability. Canceling reads as a withdrawal from all of that, a small defection, proof that you couldn’t keep up. What it is, when done from honest self-knowledge rather than chronic avoidance, is an act of accurate self-management. You assessed your actual capacity, matched it against the demand, and made a call. That’s not weakness. That’s the whole skill set applied to yourself.

There’s a difference worth naming between canceling from honest self-knowledge and canceling from avoidance, because they can look identical from the outside but feel completely different from the inside. Avoidance is the slow accumulation of exits — the pattern of escape dressed up as self-care. Honest self-knowledge is a specific, present-tense read: not I don’t feel like it but I genuinely don’t have what this requires tonight, and showing up hollow serves no one. The question worth sitting with, before you send the text, is which one is true. Not as a trap or a guilt mechanism — as a genuine inquiry. You usually know the difference. The body knows before the mind finishes the sentence.

What you owe the people you’re canceling on is honesty, reasonable notice, and the genuine intention to reschedule. What you don’t owe them is a performance of yourself at a cost you can’t afford. The relationships worth having are sturdy enough to absorb an occasional cancellation made in good faith. The ones that can’t tolerate it are telling you something worth knowing.

And here is the thing that tends not to get said in conversations about self-care or any of the other words that have been handled so much they’ve gone a little soft: protecting your capacity isn’t only about you. The version of you that shows up rested, present, and genuinely available is a gift to everyone in the room. The version that pushed through out of obligation and is now moving through the evening on fumes — that person is there in body only, and everyone can feel it, including you. Honoring your actual limits isn’t withdrawal from community. It’s how you stay in it, over time, without burning down.

There will be commitments you keep even when it costs you, and you should — some things are worth the cost, and following through on hard promises is part of what integrity looks like in practice. But there will also be days like that Wednesday, when the honest answer is that you need to stop, and the most emotionally intelligent thing you can do is say so. Not every week. Not as a pattern. But when it’s true, said plainly, as an act of care — for yourself, and for the person on the other end of the call who deserves your real presence, not what’s left of it.

The guilt that arrives before you’re supposed to be somewhere you can’t reach — that’s worth paying attention to. It’s usually telling you something real. The question is whether you’re willing to hear it, and then willing to act on what you heard.

There’s more conversation happening over at The Mystical Seeker — we’d love to have you there.

Peace and every good.

Jim Vaive is co-founder of spirit of EQ and author of The Mystical Seeker, writing at the intersection of emotional intelligence, the Enneagram, and contemplative spirituality. He and his wife Lynette help individuals and organizations grow from the inside out.

 

I Damaged Someone & The Truth It Taught Me

There is a picture my mother drew of my father in his studio. He is standing at the canvas with a brush in his hand, but he is not painting. He is looking. Just looking. My mother told me once that the hardest thing about being an artist is not the making — it is the seeing. Seeing what is there, not what you hoped would be there. Seeing clearly enough to know when something is wrong, even when the wrong thing is something you made.

I have thought about that picture a lot over the years. Especially in relation to leadership. Because leadership, at its most honest, requires the same thing my father was doing in that studio: the willingness to stand before what is real and see it — not manage it, not spin it, not quietly maneuver around it — but see it. And the hardest version of that seeing is always the one that turns inward.

When Lynette and I were building the spirit of EQ framework, we kept returning to a question that came up repeatedly in our coaching and spiritual direction work: why do so many gifted leaders struggle with self-awareness? Not because they lack intelligence. Not because they are unkind or unserious. But because the very qualities that made them effective — decisiveness, energy, forward momentum, the ability to hold a vision and drive toward it — can become the walls of a room they eventually cannot see out of.

The Enneagram has a word for this. It calls them fixations — the grooved, automatic patterns we operate from when we are running on autopilot rather than on presence. Each type has its own shape of forgetting. And the forgetting is not dramatic. It is quiet. It accumulates. It happens in the ordinary press of days, under the ordinary pressure of responsibility, until one morning you look up and realize the wake you have been leaving behind is wider and more damaging than you ever intended.

I know this from my own life. When I co-founded Varment Guard, my business partners were good people — steady, quiet, deeply competent in their domains. But one stands out for me, he did not move fast. He did not think fast. He processed carefully, methodically, and he was almost always right. I am a classic Enneagram Eight. I move fast. I decide fast. I push hard. I burned through rooms in those early years the way a locomotive burns through a tunnel — arriving on the other side with energy to spare, rarely pausing to consider what the air felt like for everyone else inside.

In the beginning, this particular partner and I worked well together. His steadiness balanced my fire. My drive opened doors his caution would have approached more slowly. But as the business grew and the pressure intensified, I lost access to that balance. I stopped seeing my partner clearly. I started seeing only the pace I needed us to keep, and I began — unconsciously, relentlessly — forcing this gentle soul into a shape that was not his. I pushed him beyond the edges of who he was. I did not mean to damage him. But I did. And eventually, he left. Not loudly. Not in conflict. He simply found a way out, and the relationship went with him. It was a wound I have carried for a long time.

What I could not see then — and what took years of coaching, spiritual direction, and a lot of sitting still to begin to understand — was that the truth I needed to face was not about the business. It was about me. The Eight’s deep gift is strength. The Eight’s deep shadow is the refusal to acknowledge the harm that strength can do. I had confused impact with intention. I believed that because I did not mean harm, I had not caused it. That is not how it works. That is not how it has ever worked.

The contemplative tradition is clear about this. Howard Thurman wrote that we are responsible not only for our intentions but for the world we create around us — the quality of the field we generate for those in our care. Julian of Norwich, writing from her anchorite cell in fourteenth-century Norwich, described the interior life as a dwelling place — something that requires tending, requires honest inspection, requires the willingness to see what is there rather than what we prefer to believe is there. “All shall be well,” she wrote — but the path to that wellbeing runs directly through the truth, not around it (Julian of Norwich, Revelations of Divine Love).

The research on emotional intelligence affirms what the mystics knew intuitively. Six Seconds, the global EQ nonprofit where Lynette and I served for many years, identifies self-awareness as foundational to every other capacity in the emotional intelligence model. You cannot regulate what you cannot see. You cannot choose your response when you are unconscious of your pattern. You cannot lead others toward wholeness from a place of unexamined wounding. The data bears this out across industries, cultures, and leadership contexts. Self-awareness is not a soft skill. It is the load-bearing wall.

But here is the thing about truth: it requires courage, not just curiosity. Many leaders are curious about themselves in a managed way — they take the assessments, they read the books, they sit in the leadership retreats. What is rarer is the willingness to let the truth land. To let it cost something. To sit with it long enough that it changes not just your language but your behavior, your relationships, the shape of the wake you leave. The contemplative teacher Thomas Keating called this the dismantling of the false self — the slow, sometimes painful process of releasing the persona we have constructed to protect ourselves and facing what is underneath (Thomas Keating, Open Mind, Open Heart). Most of us will do almost anything to avoid that process. Leaders perhaps most of all, because the stakes feel so high and the exposure feels so total.

John O’Donohue, the Irish poet and philosopher, wrote that “the longest journey you will ever make is from your head to your heart” (John O’Donohue, Anam Cara). I think of that line often when I am sitting with a leader in a coaching session, watching them circle a truth they cannot quite bring themselves to name. The truth is right there. They can feel it. But the distance between knowing it in the mind and letting it descend into the heart — into lived acknowledgment, into genuine accountability — can feel enormous. That journey is the work. And no amount of strategy, no quarterly planning cycle, no leadership competency framework can do it for you.

What helps? In our experience at spirit of EQ, several things. The practice of silence — not productivity, not journaling as output, but genuine quiet that creates the interior space for truth to surface. The practice of honest relationship — at least one person in your life who is not dependent on you, not intimidated by you, and will tell you what they see. The Enneagram, used not as a typology to explain yourself but as a mirror to face yourself. And prayer — whatever form that takes for you — as an act of opening, of consenting to be seen more fully than you can see yourself.

I did not get a chance to repair things with my partner. That is a grief I live with. But what his departure gave me — painfully, slowly, over years — was the beginning of something more honest in myself. A willingness to slow down long enough to feel the field I was generating. A willingness to ask not just “Did we hit the goal?” but “What did it cost the people in the room?” That shift did not diminish my leadership. It deepened it. It made me someone I am still, imperfectly, trying to become.

The Truth Leaders Don’t Want to Face

My father’s picture still lives in my mind. The brush in his hand. The stillness of his looking. The courage required to see clearly enough to know what is true and what is wish. That is the invitation for every leader who is willing — not to be perfect, not to have it all resolved, but to stand before the canvas of your own life and look.

The truth will not destroy you. It will, in time, free you.

If this reflection stirred something in you, we’d love to have you join us at mysticalseeker.substack.com — where we explore the inner journey of leadership, EQ, and spiritual formation.

Peace and every good.

mystical seeker.substack.com

The Most Intelligent Thing You Can Do Is Slow Down

When You Know Why You React, You Can Choose How You Respond

What the Enneagram and emotional intelligence reveal about the space between trigger and response

There is a photograph I keep coming back to in my mind — not an actual photograph, but the kind that forms over years of sitting across from people in coaching conversations. It is the image of a person mid-sentence, eyes slightly wide, voice pitched a half-step higher than usual, saying something they will probably wish they hadn’t. And in the moment before the words arrive, there is this invisible space — a fraction of a second, maybe less — where everything that matters is happening.

Viktor Frankl called it the space between stimulus and response. He wrote about it from inside a concentration camp, which means he earned the right to talk about it. That space, he said, is where our freedom lives. It is also, I’ve come to believe, where emotional intelligence and the Enneagram converge into something genuinely transformative.

The Intelligence Beneath the Surface

Emotional intelligence, as Daniel Goleman mapped it, begins with self-awareness — the capacity to notice what’s happening inside you before it moves through you and into the world. Josh Freedman of Six Seconds distills it differently, into a sequence I return to often: Know Yourself, Choose Yourself, Give Yourself. The knowing comes first. Without it, we are largely reactive — moved by currents we can’t name.

Most of us have experienced this. A colleague’s offhand comment lands wrong and we feel our jaw tighten before we understand why. A family member raises a familiar complaint and we hear ourselves responding in the old way again — the way we promised ourselves we wouldn’t. The reaction isn’t irrational exactly. It’s just faster than our awareness.

This is where the Enneagram enters the room.

A Map of the Interior

The Enneagram is a nine-type system of personality that goes deeper than behavior into motivation — into the core fears and longings that drive us. It is not a label to be worn comfortably. At its best, it is an unsettling mirror, one that shows you not only what you do but why, and what you are protecting when you do it.

A Type Eight (the Challenger) doesn’t lead aggressively because they are cruel. They lead that way because somewhere underneath the forcefulness is a terror of being controlled or betrayed — and strength feels like the only reliable protection. A Type Two (the Helper) doesn’t overextend themselves because they are foolish. They do it because their worth, in some deep and often unconscious way, feels contingent on being needed.

When you understand this about yourself — really understand it, not just intellectually but in the body — something shifts. The reaction doesn’t disappear. But there is more space around it.

The Place Where They Meet

I’ve seen this play out in workshops and in one-on-one coaching more times than I can count. A leadership team I worked with had a Type Eight and a Type Nine in constant friction. The Eight moved fast, spoke bluntly, made decisions before the Nine felt heard. The Nine withdrew, agreed on the surface, and then quietly undermined the direction — not out of malice but out of a desperate need for harmony they didn’t know how to ask for. What made it harder was that both of them were genuinely trying. The Eight believed clarity and decisiveness were acts of respect — waste no one’s time, say what’s true, move forward. The Nine believed keeping the peace was its own form of care — absorb the friction, hold the group together, avoid the rupture. Neither of them was wrong exactly. They were just operating from entirely different interior maps, and no one had ever handed them the other person’s.

When we named what was happening through the lens of both the Enneagram and emotional intelligence, something loosened. The Eight didn’t need to become soft. The Nine didn’t need to become confrontational. They needed to understand each other’s interior logic — and then, from that understanding, choose something different than their default. What I watched happen in that room was not a personality makeover. It was something quieter and more durable: two people recognizing that the other person’s behavior had a reason, and that the reason wasn’t contempt or weakness. That recognition created enough safety for genuine conversation — maybe for the first time in years of working together.

That’s the intersection. The Enneagram names what’s underneath. Emotional intelligence gives you tools to work with it. Together, they create the conditions for what I’d call non-reactive presence — the ability to be fully in a difficult moment without being fully hijacked by it.

Some Places to Begin

If this is new territory for you, here are a few entry points worth sitting with:

  1. Get curious before you get defensive. The next time you feel a strong reaction — irritation, anxiety, the urge to withdraw or escalate — ask yourself what it’s protecting. Not in a clinical way, but genuinely. What’s at stake for me right now?
  2. Learn your Enneagram type as a spiritual practice, not a personality quiz. The Narrative Enneagram tradition invites you into the type through lived experience and community, not just a test score. There’s a difference.
  3. Practice the pause. Frankl’s space between stimulus and response can be cultivated. Centering Prayer, mindful breathing, simple body awareness — any practice that builds your capacity to notice before acting will serve you here.
  4. Make it relational. Understanding your own type is valuable. Understanding the types of the people you love and work with alongside yours is where transformation tends to happen. The framework becomes a bridge rather than a mirror.

I don’t think any of us become non-reactive all the way down. That would require not being human. But I do believe we can cultivate the capacity to meet our reactions with a little more light and a little less automatic machinery. The Enneagram helps us see ourselves clearly. Emotional intelligence gives us something to do with what we see.

That space between stimulus and response — Frankl was right. Something important lives there. And with practice, we can learn to inhabit it.

If you’re curious about exploring the Enneagram and EQ together — for yourself, your team, or your community — visit spiritofeq.com to learn more about our workshops and coaching.

Peace and every good.

— — —

Subscribe to The Mystical Seeker on Substack  — in-depth posts on the contemplative life